Judge’s decision urges Dover Planning Board to take ‘hard look’ at Transco substation

DOVER PLAINS — A decision by New York Supreme Court Judge Thomas Davis in late August denied New York Transco permission to construct and run a power substation on a former auto wrecking site on Route 22 near Cricket Hill Road that borders on an important wetland.

The Dover Planning Board had granted permission to the company in February, but a coalition of local environmental groups and residents argued that in planning this project, there was insufficient attention paid to the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQR). 

The judge remanded the matter to the Town of Dover Planning Board to take a “hard look” at the areas of environmental concern. The Town of Dover filed an appeal but withdrew its appeal several days later.

Transco’s communications director Shannon Baxevanis, said, “We’re internally considering our options and the timing. We can keep you updated as we execute next steps.”

Transco’s request for permission from the Planning Board began in April 2021, when it was leasing and in contract to purchase the site, which is “…adjacent and to the north of the Cricket Hill Preserve, (also locally known as the Great Swamp), which is a National Historic Landmark, a New York State-designated Critical Environmental Area, and a Class I wetland,” according to the decision.

The company’s formal application followed in October 2021, after a meeting and various correspondence with the Planning Board, which declared itself a lead agency in conducting the review.

The project’s intention is to install a Phase Angle Regulator (PAR), which is a specialized form of transformer used to control the flow of real power on three-phase electric transmission. Over the next year, Transco appeared at the Planning Board’s meetings to discuss it and retained experts to address questions from the board and the board’s own experts, attorney Victoria Polidoro, planner Aaron Werner, and engineer Joe Berger.

In a July 2022 letter, Transco, having submitted numerous documents to bolster its case, maintained that “there are no reported spills at the Site…and it was not listed on DEC’s Environmental Site Remediation database.”

 In sum, it concluded, “The planned area of disturbance on the Site is small, relative to the scale of the overall system which feeds water into the Great Swamp.” Public hearing on the project was from September 2022 to Feb. 1, 2023.

The coalition of environmental and conservation groups—Friends of the Great Swamp (FrOGS), Concerned Citizens of Dover (CCD) and the Oblong Land Conservancy—attended Planning Board meetings and voiced their concerns and supplied counterarguments.

FrOGS’ James Utter, who is its board  chair, faulted Transco’s soil and groundwater testing  as “inadequate and unclear, in that only very few samples were taken, the locations of the samples were not in areas where many of the junkyard vehicles had historically been stored and, though dozens of contaminants (some known carcinogens) were listed as having been detected in the samples, none of the actual data from the testing results was supplied by Transco.” 

In referring to a graph that Transco submitted as proof of lack of current and potential damage, the judge’s decision read: “In the three-column graph that had been submitted as above, (Analyte/substance, Applicable Use Standard” and ‘Exceedance of...standard, respectively) there was no underlying data, i.e., numerical concentration for each analyte, which would have revealed “how close the testing came to exceeding the limits.”

Both the Planning Board and the coalition members requested that Transco reveal the relevant data, but the graph and other documents were admitted as sufficient by five out of the seven Planning Board members, which granted Transco the permission to continue. One board member voted against the project,  and one was absent when Chair Ryan Courtien announced the Feb. 6, 2023, approval of Transco’s plan. 

Coalition members followed with a Notice of Petition on March 8, 2023, to annul the decision and to prevent any further “site disturbance,” which culminated in the Aug. 28 decision by Judge Davis. Named as petitioners were FrOGS, the Oblong Land Conservancy, CCD, and Charles A. Quimby, with the Town of Dover, Transco LLC, and Consolidated Edison Company of New York Inc. as respondents.

For its part, the coalition of environmentalists and other residents is quietly optimistic. “We came together with a shared goal: to protect the land, water, and biodiversity that sustain us,” said Quimby, a founding member of CCD. “We believe in responsible progress and have hope that [this] court ruling will impact future development decisions in our town.”

Latest News

Severe flu season strains hospitals, schools, care facilities across the region

Dr. Mark Marshall, an internist at Sharon Hospital, said, “The statistics suggest it’s the worst flu season in 30 years.”

Photo by Bridget Starr Taylor

A severe and fast-moving flu season is straining health care systems on both sides of the state line, with Connecticut and New York reporting “very high” levels of respiratory illness activity.

Hospitals, schools and clinics are seeing a surge in influenza cases—a trend now being felt acutely across the Northwest Corner.

Keep ReadingShow less
Demonstrators in Salisbury call for justice, accountability

Ed Sheehy and Tom Taylor of Copake, New York, and Karen and Wendy Erickson of Sheffield, Massachusetts, traveled to Salisbury on Saturday to voice their anger with the Trump administration.

Photo by Alec Linden

SALISBURY — Impassioned residents of the Northwest Corner and adjacent regions in Massachusetts and New York took to the Memorial Green Saturday morning, Jan. 10, to protest the recent killing of Minneapolis resident Renee Nicole Good at the hands of a federal immigration agent.

Good, a 37-year-old mother of three, was shot at close range by an officerwith Immigration and Customs Enforcement, commonly known as ICE, on Wednesday, Jan. 7. She and her wife were participating in a protest opposing the agency’s presence in a Minneapolis neighborhood at the time of the shooting.

Keep ReadingShow less
Northern Dutchess Paramedics remains in service amid changes at Sharon Hospital

Area ambulance squad members, along with several first selectmen, attend a Jan. 5 meeting on emergency service providers hosted by Nuvance/Northwell.

Photo by Ruth Epstein

FALLS VILLAGE, Conn. — Paramedic coverage in the Northwest Corner is continuing despite concerns raised last month after Sharon Hospital announced it would not renew its long-standing sponsorship agreement with Northern Dutchess Paramedics.

Northern Dutchess Paramedics (NDP), which has provided advanced life support services in the region for decades, is still responding to calls and will now operate alongside a hospital-based paramedic service being developed by Sharon Hospital, officials said at a public meeting Monday, Jan. 5, at the Falls Village Emergency Services Center.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Stop Shepherd’s Run’ rally draws 100-plus crowd in Copake

Gabrielle Tessler, of Copake, writes on a large sheet of paper expressing her opposition to the project as speakers address more than 100 attendees at a community meeting Saturday, Jan. 10, at Copake’s Memorial Park Building.

Photo by John Coston

COPAKE — There was standing room only on Saturday, Jan. 10, when more than 100residents attended a community meeting to hear experts and ask questions about the proposed 42-megawatt Shepherd’s Run solar project that has been given draft approval by New York State.

The parking lot at the Copake Memorial Park Building was filled, and inside Sensible Solar for Rural New York and Arcadian Alliance, two citizen groups, presented a program that included speeches, Q&A, videos and workshop-like setups.

Keep ReadingShow less