Amenia site approval lands Planning Board in court

Amenia site approval lands
Planning Board in court

Amenia Town Hall

John Coston

AMENIA — The Town of Amenia Planning Board’s decision to grant a waiver permitting construction of a house on a scenic ridgeline has landed in State Supreme Court in Dutchess County.

Petitions from a local farming family have been filed in the court seeking a judgment annulling the Planning Board’s actions through an Article 78 proceeding.

Article 78 lawsuits are used to challenge actions taken by state or local governments.

Barbara C. Meili, Joerg E. Meili and Arrowhead Hills Partners L.P. are members of a local farming family that have owned several properties contiguous to or near the ridgeline property for decades, according to court filings.

Cameron O. Smith and Liza Vann Smith own the ridgeline land on 27 acres at 108 Westerly Ridge Drive in Amenia. Court records state they purchased the land in 2005 for $850,000. It currently is listed for sale by Compass for $1,249,000.

The land is advertised as “perched at the very top of Westerly Ridge in Amenia, and surrounded by forever protected land under DLC conservation easement, lies the most exceptional building opportunity. There are panoramic 270-degree views, far and wide down the Oblong Valley to the south, across the Amenia hills to the west, and up into Sharon to the east, offering distant and varied views of the surrounding beauty.”

The ad mentions the parcel has “an approved building envelope,” an attribute made possible by the waiver issued by the Planning Board.

The petitioners cite town code that states that site plan approval must meet a standard that is 40 feet below the crestline of any ridge and doesn’t disturb “the continuity of the treeline when viewed from a publicly accessible place.” According to the code, chimneys, satellite dishes, antennas, or cupolas may project higher, but “shall not be higher than 30 feet below the crest line.”

The Smiths’ property is in a rural agricultural zone and in a Scenic Protection Overlay (SPO) District, which is why the waiver was required for building.

In 2019, the Planning Board granted the Smiths a waiver and site plan approval, but the waiver subsequently expired. In August 2023, the Planning Board reapproved the waiver, prompting the petitioners to file their suit in the Supreme Court claiming “substantive and procedural errors” on the board’s part.

Subsequent to the September filing in Supreme Court, the Planning Board, petitioners claim, reapproved the application at an Oct. 25 meeting in an attempt “to rectify its mistakes” and address concerns raised in the lawsuit. The petitioners also claim that the Oct. 25 meeting failed to include discussion of claims made in the original petition, or of letters received by the board objecting to approval and that petitioners were not allowed to speak at the meeting.

Filings by the Planning Board and the landowners argue that the reapproval was granted upon a full record, and that the Planning Board applied the correct standard for granting a waiver. The response also states that the Smiths’ application appropriately was identified as a “minor project” and as such the board was authorized to waive a public hearing.

The board also holds that the application didn’t require an environmental review under the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQR), which calls for local agencies to examine environmental impacts along with social and economic considerations. The board also states that its approval doesn’t conflict with the town’s Comprehensive Plan.

In a recent filing on Feb. 22, the Planning Board stated: “Petitioners’ opposition to the Project, as evidenced in their submission, is simply based on Petitioners’ mere disagreement with the rational conclusion reached by the Planning Board, and not based on any deficiencies in the Planning Board’s review process.”

Justice Thomas R. Davis has the case.

Latest News

Village to hear update on wastewater project, discuss law to recognize tree committee
Village of Millerton offices on Route 22
John Coston

MILLERTON – The Village of Millerton Board of Trustees will convene on Monday, Jan. 12, for its monthly workshop meeting, with updates expected on the village’s wastewater project, Veterans Park improvements and the formal recognition of a new tree committee.

The board is scheduled to receive an update from Erin Moore – an engineer at Tighe and Bond, an engineering and consulting firm – on the status of the village’s wastewater project. The presentation will focus on funding secured to date, as well as additional grant opportunities that may be pursued to support the long-term infrastructure effort.

Keep ReadingShow less
Local massage therapist suggests ditching resolutions, ‘slow it down’ in the new year

Aimée Davis in her Millerton massage studio at 65 Main St. Davis offers massage therapy, relationship coaching and reiki in her studio and through home visits.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

MILLERTON — While many view the new year as a starting line for resolutions and new habits, Millerton-based massage therapist and relationship coach Aimée Davis suggests a different course — a marathon, not a sprint. She believes a slower, more embodied approach can lead to greater fulfillment than ticking boxes off a list.

“I’m more of a daily-moment person,” Davis said, explaining that she focuses on small, consistent practices rather than big, rushed goals. Practicing conscious living year-round allows her to forego new year’s resolutions. “I made one yesterday and I’ll make one tomorrow — I’m constantly tracking what’s coming up, what’s drifting and what I want to change.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Alexander says flipped county legislature marks new era of governance

Eric Alexander stands in front of the Millbrook Diner on Franklin Avenue in the Village of Millbrook. Alexander was elected to represent District 25 in the Dutchess County Legislature.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

MILLBROOK — Fresh off a narrow win in the race for Dutchess County Legislature, newly elected Eric Alexander — whose victory helped flip the county from red to blue — said the shift marks a “renewed commitment to good governance.” In November, Democrats took control of the legislature for the first time since 2008, and Alexander edged out his Republican opponent, Dierdre Houston, by just 41 votes.

A first-time candidate with an extensive career spanning communications and financial services, 69-year-old Alexander said, “To be able to start a new chapter at this stage of my life, I really hope I’ll be able to make a difference.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Nearly a year after fire, Millerton continues rebuilding effort

Demolition crews from BELFOR Property Restoration began demolishing the fire-ravaged Water and Highway Department building in the Village of Millerton on Oct. 27, 2025.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

MILLERTON — With another winter underway and new snow-removal equipment now in place, the village is reminded of the February morning when a fire destroyed Millerton’s highway and water department building on Route 22, wiping out everything inside and setting off a year of recovery and rebuilding. The blaze broke out in the early hours of Feb. 3, as snow covered the ground.

Demolition and planning

Keep ReadingShow less