ZBA rejects attempt to reopen 20-year dispute over illegal Cooper Road home

ZBA rejects attempt to reopen 20-year dispute over illegal Cooper Road home

Zoning Board of Appeals chair Edie Greenwood hears comments from board member Jeff Stark during a regular meeting of the board on Thursday, Feb. 19.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

MILLERTON — The Town of North East Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) voted Thursday, Feb. 19, to formally deny a request that would have reopened a 20-year-old dispute over an illegal dwelling on Cooper Road, bringing the latest chapter of the long-running Vitiello case to a close — and leaving the future of the property unresolved.

The rehearing request, filed in September 2025 by Josephine and Erasmo Vitiello, sought to revisit a 2005 ZBA decision related to the legality of their dwelling — a home located in a landlocked wood lot that has never received a certificate of occupancy.

Although the structure received a building permit in 2005, Town Attorney Warren Replansky has said it was approved as a shed but built as a single-family residence without the required public road frontage. It remains illegal under the town’s zoning code and litigation between the town and homeowners in 2018 resulted in an injunction requiring the property to be vacated.

The home, however, remains occupied, prompting public questions about enforcement by the Town Board. Thursday’s meeting served as the board’s final opportunity to determine whether it would reopen the case. The ZBA declined to do so, voting 3-1 to adopt a formal resolution written by Replansky denying the request.

The vote leaves the original ZBA ruling in place and affirms that the board will not consider whether the structure can be legalized. The future of the property is now back in the hands of the town’s zoning enforcement powers, returning to a status quo that has left residents of the illegal dwelling and neighbors uncertain about next steps.

While the agenda framed the item as a “review and vote on the decision for the reconsideration,” the board’s discussion shifted to broader questions about the legality of decisions made decades ago.

Board member Jeff Stark attempted to introduce a motion to re-hear the original 2005 determination, arguing that the ZBA’s original ruling contained legal errors — specifically that the board had imposed conditions it did not have the authority to impose and overstepped into the jurisdiction of the highway superintendent and town engineer.

No board member seconded Stark’s motion.

The decision ends the Vitiellos’ attempt to revive the zoning case through the ZBA, the latest chapter of a dispute that has dragged on for years.

Stark, in a lengthy statement entered into the record, argued that the 2005 decision should be clarified to remove conditions the ZBA had no legal power to enforce and to make clear that any path forward lies outside of the ZBA. Other board members did not respond on his comments.

Latest News

‘Maple Syrup Madness’ draws visitors to Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo for sweet treats

Dan Cohen, left, dispenses whipped cream on a plate of maple syrup treats during a demonstration on the making of maple syrup at Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo on Millbrook School’s campus.

Photos by Aly Morrissey

MILLBROOK — The Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo hosted its sixth annual Maple Syrup Madness Weekend on March 7 and 8, drawing visitors eager to sample fresh maple syrup, learn about the sugaring process and enjoy one of the region’s sweetest seasonal activities. The event will continue March 14 and 15, as long as the sap continues to flow, organizers said.

Visitors were treated to free tastings of locally made maple syrup with a side of waffles, while Alan Tousignant — a woodworker, syrup maker and director of the Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo — led demonstrations showing how sap collected from nearby maple trees is transformed into syrup.

Keep ReadingShow less
Stanford parents call for more representation in school closure talks

Cold Spring Early Learning Center on Homan Road in Stanford. Pine Plains school district officials proposed closing the building last year citing budget constraints and declining enrollment.

Photo by Nathan Miller

STANFORD — Community members gathered on Wednesday, March 4, for a first look at a newly-formed committee that will analyze the impact of closing an elementary school building in the Pine Plains Central School District.

Town Supervisor Julia Descoteaux arranged the Wednesday meeting at Stanford Town Hall to find volunteers to represent the town in the district-wide Building Utilization Advisory Committee. The committee's first district-wide meeting is scheduled for Thursday, March 12.

Keep ReadingShow less

Accuracy and reputation key to local news

Accuracy and reputation key to local news

Publisher James Clark, left, and Executive Editor Christian Murray speak at Scoville Memorial Library March 7.

Photo by Patrick L. Sullivan

SALISBURY — What makes or breaks a local newspaper is its reputation, Lakeville Journal Executive Editor Christian Murray said at the Scoville Memorial Library Saturday, March 7.

Murray and publisher James Clark led a discussion at the library that was originally scheduled for January, but the weather intervened.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Library building expected to reopen one month after burst pipe floods basement

The Millerton fire crew watches a pump hose carry water from the NorthEast-Millerton Library’s basement on Tuesday, Feb. 10.

Photo by Nathan Miller

MILLERTON — Library officials expect the NorthEast-Millerton Library to be fully open the weekend of March 14-15, a full month after a burst pipe forced librarians to move operations to the annex building on Century Boulevard.

Executive Director Rhiannon Leo-Jameson said the temporary relocation has been stressful, but library patrons have been understanding and using the library to the fullest extent possible.

Keep ReadingShow less

Alfred Lyon Ivry

Alfred Lyon Ivry

SALISBURY — Alfred Lyon Ivry, a long-time resident of Salisbury, and son of Belle (Malamud) and Morris Ivry, died in Bergen County, New Jersey, on Feb. 12 at the age of 91, surrounded by family members. Born and raised in Brooklyn, he was a graduate ofAbraham Lincoln High School and Brooklyn College, where he earned a B.A. in English literature and Philosophy and served as drama critic for the school paper.

Alfred earned a PhD in Medieval Jewish Philosophy from Brandeis University in Waltham, Massachusetts in 1963 and in 1971 was awarded a D. Phil in Medieval Islamic Philosophy from Oxford University, Linacre College.

Keep ReadingShow less

Larry Power

Larry Power

LAKEVILLE — Larry Power passed away peacefully at home on March 9, 2026.

Larry was born at St. Vincent’s Hospital in New York City in 1939.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.