Solar projects in Dutchess and Columbia counties have become entangled in legal and regulatory netting that involves a number of issues, including finding a balance between New York state’s decarbonization targets and what residents and towns want in their communities.

In Pine Plains, a group of residents has taken the town to task for granting a special use permit to a New York City group that wants to build a solar plant on farmland near Pulvers Corners. The residents filed their action in New York Supreme Court and the case is set to be heard in Putnam County.

A half-hour’s drive north, in Copake, another project is on ropes. Shepherd’s Run Solar Farm is planned by a Chicago-based firm that wants to build a significantly larger solar facility on farmland along routes 23 and 7. That project is stalled because the company lost control of some the land planned for inclusion from the start, and now the submitted design no longer mirrors real-life feasibility, enabling the town and other residents to enter a motion to quash the project.

Both projects are sited on farmland. One’s fate has landed in New York Supreme Court, the other’s on the desks of an administrative law judge and the New York State Office of Renewable Energy Siting in Albany.

Both these projects are part of New York state’s plan to achieve 70% renewable electricity by 2030 and 100% emissions-free electricity by 2040. That’s only around the corner, given the way time flies and major construction projects subject to government regulation tend only to crawl along. The goals itself are already aging; they were established by the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act, a landmark bill passed in 2019 by the New York State Legislature.

As of 2020, more than 25% of New York’s electricity generation came from renewable sources, according to the New York State Energy and Research Development Authority. The U.S. Energy and Information Administration (EIA) reports that in 2022, 51% of power generation in the state came from renewable sources like solar and wind as well as nuclear power. The EIA notes that New York consumes less energy per capita than residents in all but one other state, and that per capita energy-related carbon dioxide emissions are “consistently lower than those of any other state in the nation.”

Getting back to Pine Plains and Copake. Pulvers Corners’ case has bounced from one judge to another — five judges recused themselves — but the case will be heard in Putnam County “at a date to be determined.” While the town of Copake has moved to have the Shepherd’s Run project dismissed, others in the rural hamlet support it, citing last summer’s Canadian wildfire smoke and deluges across the region as evidence of a climate crisis that needs to be addressed.

Today’s rural solar projects fall in a crosshair of the New York State Constitution (Article 14, Section 4), which states on the one hand that “the policy of the state shall be to conserve and protect its natural resources and scenic beauty and encourage the development and improvement of its agricultural lands for the production of food,” and on the other, that this policy “shall include adequate provision for the abatement of air and water pollution.”

In the untangling of these contradictory good intentions, elected judges, volunteer town representatives, state administrators and regular citizens are all playing a part.

Latest News

Millerton trustees ease parking rules for business district, advance pool and park plans

An artist’s rendering shows what the pool and pool house at Eddie Collins Park could look like. During a meeting on Monday, Dec. 15, Village of Millerton Trustees decided against heating the pool to reduce costs.

Illustration provided

MILLERTON — The Village of Millerton Board of Trustees approved a local law on Monday, Dec. 15, that will ease parking restrictions in the village’s General Business District. The law was immediately passed following a public hearing.

The local law amends Chapter 170 of the Village Code, titled Zoning, by eliminating off-street parking requirements for changes of use within existing structures in the General Business District. Under the amendment, “no additional off-street parking spaces shall be required to convert space within an existing structure in the General Business District from one use or occupancy to another, even if such proposed new use would increase demand for parking.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Millerton highway crew ready for winter after fire and yearlong rebuild

William J. Clark, Jim Milton, Joseph Olenik and Spencer Parks make up the village highway department and pose in front of new snow removal equipment.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

MILLERTON — Winter may not officially begin until Dec. 21, but snow has already arrived in Millerton. The early snowfall comes after nearly a year of rebuilding following a February fire that destroyed the village’s highway and water structure, along with all of its snow removal equipment. That long recovery makes this winter’s readiness especially significant for the village.

The Village Highway Department is the small but mighty crew that keeps the roads and sidewalks safe, and not only do crew members feel prepared for the colder months, they’ve already been tested by several early-season snowfalls.

Keep ReadingShow less
Millbrook board advances plans for Thorne Building community center

The Thorne Building on Franklin Avenue in Millbrook, built in the 1890s and vacant for decades, is slated for renovation into a community arts and cultural center.

By Nathan Miller

MILLBROOK – Plans to renovate the historic Thorne Building on Franklin Avenue, built in the 1890s, into a community center moved forward Monday, Dec. 8, as the Millbrook Planning Board accepted an application for the project, which is scheduled for review early next year.

“The Thorne Building has been a landmark building,” said architect Michael Sloan of Millbrook, describing its history as a school for the Village of Millbrook. After the village constructed a new elementary and high school, use of the building declined, and by the mid-1990s it had fallen into disrepair. Sloan said the building has been vacant for roughly 20 years.

Keep ReadingShow less
North East Town Board approves truck loan, hears school funding concerns

North East Town Hall on Maple Avenue in Millerton.

Photo by Nathan Miller

MILLERTON — North East Town Board members approved a $168,000 loan from the Bank of Millbrook to purchase a new truck for the town’s Highway Department at their regular meeting Thursday, Dec. 11.

The meeting marked the board’s final session of the year.

Keep ReadingShow less