New restaurant considers former McDonald’s location

New restaurant considers former McDonald’s location

Pending approval from the Planning Board, the former site of McDonald’s on Route 44 in Millerton has been proposed as the new home of Tallow, an alternative to traditional fast-food.

Photo by Krista A. Briggs

MILLERTON — After a vacancy of over eight years, the former McDonald’s building on Route 44 may soon have a new occupant in Tallow, a nutrient-conscious eatery that hopes to be in construction by the spring.

As for its former occupant, McDonald’s is not expected to return to the area. The closest McDonald’s is located in Canaan, Connecticut, about 14 miles away. The next closest McDonald’s is in Dover Plains.

Millerton is expected to be Tallow’s first location. On its website, it bills itself as “fast food that is actually good for you.

“The problem that we’re trying to solve is to regenerate health in people,” said co-founder Austin Cornell. “How we’re doing it is very simply to just source real ingredients from local regenerative farms to get the most nutrient-dense food as possible into those who really need it most.”

As fast-food pricing continues to rise, customers are now paying more money for lesser ingredients. According to Tallow’s website, its smashburger will be priced at $18. Though a notch above fast food prices, the ingredients are of a higher standard than many fast-food restaurants, and it is priced lower than many farm-to-table eateries in the region. “We’re serving burgers and grilled cheese and chicken sandwiches and a few other things,” Cornell said. “A very simple menu with the most nutrient-dense, pesticide-free, highest-quality ingredients we can find locally.”

According to Tallow’s website, highly processed vegetable oils which come from plant seeds — corn, sunflower, canola, etc. — make up 30% of American calories. Around 1990, many fast food chains switched from frying food in tallow — animal fat — to seed oils in order to save money. Tallow plans to utilize local ingredients, regeneratively sourced meats, chemical-free produce and will fry its food in 100 percent grass-fed beef tallow.

Nate Long, co-founder and head chef, previously worked at The Inn at Little Washington in Virginia, a Michelin three-star restaurant, under Chef Patrick O’Connell. Long has butchered for the Organic Butcher of McLean, Va,. which was listed as the top butcher shop in America in USA Today. As an independent chef, Long creates elaborate six-course menus for private dinner clients. “I’ve recruited a co-founder who has 10 years experience in the food industry. He’s a chef trained down in Virginia,” said Cornell. “And is coming on board to run, to really run the menu, and to lead the team in the kitchen.”

Cornell struggled with obesity and chronic fatigue as a teenager, and was working to improve his health while growing up. After trying “every fad diet,” he decided to cut out processed foods and worked with a personal trainer, losing 60 pounds as a result. “This experience taught me two vital lessons: anything is possible, and a real food diet is essential to health,” as Cornell explained on Tallow’s website. “In recent years, I’ve learned about the toxicity of our food system, the misleading advice from so-called health ‘experts,’ and what’s truly necessary for health.”

To help build customer loyalty, Tallow is creating a paid membership program for in-store discounts, community events and bi-weekly Sunday six-course dinners. Cornell hopes to bring the site proposal to the Planning Board by mid-February with an aim for construction to begin in March. “We have such great farms around us,” Cornell said. ”Some of the best regenerative farms that I’ve visited are within a 15-20 minute radius…If anyone locally would be interested in supporting the mission, that is my main goal right now.”

Latest News

Millerton, snowmobiles, homes, businesses

The following excerpts from The Millerton News were compiled by Kathleen Spahn and Rhiannon Leo-Jameson of the North East-Millerton Library.

January 24, 1935

Keep ReadingShow less
Gen Z is facing hard times despite a growing economy

The college-age generation is grappling with inflation, increasing housing prices, climate change, and now mass corporate layoffs. In a world where geopolitical turmoil is increasing, the ground beneath their feet is shifting. Many believe their future is bleak.

My nephew, Joey, just got married. His wife lives with her parents, and he lives with his. While he makes good money as a pharmacy manager at a national chain drugstore, neither he nor his wife can afford even a down payment on a house in Long Island. They are moving in with the wife’s parents. Joey’s sister is also married with two children. They also live with their parents. Welcome to the American dream turned nightmare for almost 70 million young Americans.

Keep ReadingShow less
Rounders camp inducts first woman in club’s history

Caroline Farr-Killmer wears her hunting bibs after being inducted into the historic Rounders’ Hunting Club in November 2025, becoming the first woman to join the club since it was founded by World War II veterans in 1954.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

MILLERTON — A lot has changed for Caroline Farr-Killmer over the last two decades, but the smell of campfire smoke and the familiar bark of an old blue alarm clock have stood the test of time at the hunting grounds of the historic Rounders club, a place that has served as a second home for her family for generations.

In November 2025, Farr-Killmer, 25, became the first adult woman to be unanimously voted into the hunting club, a group that’s known as much for its camaraderie and history as its dedication to safety, respect and the outdoors.

Keep ReadingShow less
Dutchess County among three selected for state childcare pilot

The North East Community Center’s Early Learning Program shuttered abruptly last December after nonprofit leadership announced that significant financial strain required the program’s termination. NECC Executive Director Christine Sergent said the organization remains open to reconsidering childcare in the future.

Photo by Nathan miller

Dutchess County is one of three counties selected to receive significant state funding as part of a new childcare pilot program announced by Gov. Kathy Hochul last week — an initiative that could expand childcare options in rural communities like Millerton.

The announcement follows Hochul’s State of the State address in which she proposed a landmark $4.5 billion investment toward universal childcare in New York. Hochul visited a childcare center in Queens on Thursday, Jan. 15, to outline her vision for the rollout of the pilot program, which would include a total of $60 million in state funding, along with additional funding from each of the three counties — Dutchess, Monroe and Broome — with a particular focus on serving newborns to three-year-olds.

Keep ReadingShow less