Thank you!
Your gift keeps The Millerton News in our towns.

Trump’s “Classical architecture”mandates

Occasional Observer

As an architectural student in Philadelphia in the 1960s, I used to come frequently to New York, arriving by train at the magnificent Pennsylvania Station, designed by the country’s most famous architects, McKim, Mead and White, to recall the Baths of Caracalla in Rome. My architectural schooling happened to coincide with the planned destruction of Penn Station; every time I passed through this Beaux Arts masterpiece it was a little smaller as it suffered a ruthless demolition. The sad scene made even Jackie Kennedy, who went on to help establish the New York City Landmark Preservation Commission, cry.

I am totally in favor of historic preservation. But it is one thing to greatly admire outstanding architecture from the distant past but something totally different to try to recreate it. The world today is so very different from that of 1800 years ago in Rome that comparisons are difficult. Most everything was different then. And today a modern train station bears little similarity to an ancient public bath.

Like nearly all architects today, I was trained to avoid thinking about style until the project I was working on was well along. Instead I was taught to gather all the significant information that might influence the final design: available construction materials and methods, site characteristics and surroundings, functional elements and their optimal arrangements, access, circulation considerations, etc. Integrating these aspects and many others usually gets one well along towards a design. But starting with a style, a picture of the end result, shortchanges all the other very important considerations and leads to a weak end result lacking authenticity.

Near the end of his first term, Trump issued an executive order mandating that “classical” architecture be the official “style” for Federal government buildings.Shortly after his inauguration a few months later President Biden rescinded Trump’s E.O. In 2022, Congressional bills by GOP Sen. Mark Rubio and Rep. Jim Banks reiterated the substance of Trump’s Executive Order.

A competing measure was introduced by Rep. Dina Titus based on guidelines carefully drawn up in 1962 by Patrick Moynihan that eschewed partisan sentiments. She noted that “Federal design guidelines should not confine all architecture to one point in history”. All three bills have languished in committees.

But a day after being sworn in for his second term, President Trump issued the following Executive Order:

“I hereby direct the Administrator of the General Services Administration in consultation with the Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and the heads of departments and agencies and the United States where necessary to submit to me within 60 days recommendations to advance the policy that Federal public buildings should be visually identifiable as civic buildings and respect regional, traditional, and classical architectural heritage in order to uplift and beautify public spaces and ennoble the United States and our system of self-government...”

Trump’s past attempts at being a “master builder” have not been well received by architectural critics. Ada Louise Huxtable’s review of the Trump Tower in Manhattan was withering: “Even with all of its pricey superglitz, it is an uncomfortable proportioned in its narrow verticality, unredeemed by the posh ladies’ powder-room decor that totally lacks the cosmopolitan style to which it so aggressively aspires”. One might wonder if such comments might have helped trigger Trump’s Executive Order.

Both of Trump’s executive orders have been roundly criticized with harsh, albeit polite denunciations from the National Trust for Historic Preservation, the American Society of Landscape Architects, the American Institute of Planners and the American Institute of Architects, not to mention thousands of letters from individual architects, nearly all of whom reiterated the idea expressed in the Moynihan document: “Design must flow from the architect to the government, not the other way around.”

Despite attempts to portray ancient Greek and Roman societies as democratic, they were far from it and their architecture expresses an autocratic society, not the more democratic sort we pride ourselves on.

In view of the momentous actions taken by the Trump administration in just its first few months, many readers may consider an Executive Order mandating a particular style of architectural design too trivial a matter for serious concern. But this mandate represents part of a larger, darker campaign to undo 250 years of democracy and shift nearly all power to the executive branch and the self-serving people now controlling it. If a dictator can determine the “style” of government buildings, where will it stop?

Architect and landscape designerMac Gordon lives in Lakeville.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Millerton News and The News does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Farm & Friends: a holiday market that gives back

The Farm & Friends holiday market returns Nov. 21 and 22, featuring local makers, food producers and seasonal gifts.

Provided

According to PBS, “More than 5 million people have lost their Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, benefits since President Trump’s so-called One Big Beautiful Bill passed last year.” Combined with rising costs and new eligibility requirements, these cuts have placed additional pressure on families struggling to make ends meet. As more people turn to food banks and pantries for assistance, local farms are playing an increasingly important role in meeting that need. Hungry Reaper Farm in Morris, for example, supplies food and CSA shares to a variety of nonprofit organizations and schools.

In Dutchess County, The Webatuck Valley Farm Collaborative is working to strengthen the pipeline from farms to foodbanks. Led by Rock Steady Farm, Sweet Freedom Farm and Wildseed Community Farm and Healing Village, the collaborative hopes to double the infrastructure capacity for at least 15 local farms. This will allow them to increase supplies for food pantries and regional schools while expanding the farms’ reach to industrial buyers and distributors. By their estimation, the food hub “will supply and impact 9 school districts, 13 food pantries, and partner with 6 institutional buyers and 8 aggregators and distributors.”

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Under the big top at Full Circus Farm

Under the big top at Full Circus Farm

Miriam Goler and Mark Stonehill with their Haflinger horses, Sunshine and Sandy, at Full Circus Farm in Pine Plains.

L. Tomaino
We share this farm with such amazing human and nonhuman neighbors.
— Mark Stonehill

For Mark Stonehill and Miriam Stonehill Goler, the founder of Full Circus Farm in Pine Plains, farming has always been about more than what comes out of the ground.

“From the very beginning, we’ve envisioned the farm as a place not only for food production, but also merriment and community,” they said.

Keep ReadingShow less
At Ancram Center, community takes center stage
Ancram Center staff and teaching artists after the ceremony.From left to right,Simone Stevens, Sarah Katan, Jeffrey Mousseau, Erin Krom and Chris McCoy.
Provided

At the Ancram Center for the Arts, the stage has been host to numerous award winning professional actors, but it also often belongs to a neighbor with a story to tell. Other times, the performance moves out of the theater altogether, transforming a pond, a field or a corner of town into a stage.

That commitment to bringing theater into the community — and the community into the theater — has earned the Ancram Center the Larry Murray Award for Community Outreach and Support through Theater, one of the Berkshire Theatre Critics Association’s annual Berkie Awards.

Keep ReadingShow less
The Cornwall Whale resurfaces in West Cornwall

The Cornwall Whale is the brain-child of visual and experiential designer Lindsay Stadig.

Provided

There’s something oddly familiar yet intangibly foreign about the Cornwall Whale. It’s not an interiors store, even though there are chairs and furnishings for sale. It’s not an art gallery, though there are paintings and sculptures occupying every corner of the space. It’s not a boutique, even with locally handmade shoes and carefully selected garments. No, The Cornwall Whale is something truly unique in the world of the truly unique.

The enigmatic shop popped up in the early winter of 2025 at the Hughes Memorial Library, right on the bank of the Housatonic River in West Cornwall. It is the brain-child of visual and experiential designer Lindsay Stadig.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.