First came the pink paint, then came questions about surveillance

First came the pink paint, then came questions about surveillance

A marker appears on South Main Street beside the Pine Plains Fire Department. Four pink markers appeared across Pine Plains on Tuesday, Feb. 3 tied to a company that sells surveillance equipment.

Photo by Patrick Grego / The New Pine Plains Herald

This article was originally published in The New Pine Plains Herald on Friday, Feb. 6, and is republished here with permission.

PINE PLAINS — Four unexplained pink markers appeared across Pine Plains on Tuesday, Feb. 3, unsettling residents and town officials and raising questions about whether surveillance equipment was being installed without local authorization. The markings — pink spray paint and wooden stakes placed on both public and private property — were later linked to Flock Safety, an Atlanta-based company that sells automated license-plate reader systems to police departments nationwide, prompting concern about who, if anyone, had approved the work and what kind of surveillance could follow.

One of the first people to notice the markings was Jeanine Sisco, a member of the Pine Plains Town Board, who on Tuesday spotted what appeared to be routine roadside work taking place across the street from her home near Patchin Mills, just north of the town center.

“I noticed a car and a traffic cone,” Sisco said. “They were spraying pink paint and driving stakes into the ground.”

At first, she said, it did not seem unusual. “I didn’t think anything of it, because there’s been a lot of stuff going on with wiring with Central Hudson,” she said.

But her husband, Keith, walked outside to ask what was happening.

“The individual said that he was with Flock Safety, and he was marking places where these devices would be installed,” Sisco said. The devices, Keith was told, were pole-mounted, solar-powered, license-plate reader cameras.

“They said they were actually installing one on my property,” Sisco recalled. “My husband said, ‘I have no knowledge of this, and this is private property.’”

By the end of the day, Flock Safety had marked three other locations near the center of Pine Plains — one adjacent to the firehouse sign on South Main Street, a second at 2991 Church St. across from St. Anthony’s Catholic Church, and a third along Route 83 in front of Heeler Farms.

Michael Carone, the owner of Heeler Farms, told the Herald that as of Thursday afternoon he was unaware of the marker and of any plans to install surveillance technology in front of his farm.

Paris Lewbel, a public relations manager for Flock Safety, said: “We don’t install on private property unless we have a contract with that property owner. If it’s a city, it would be on the city right-of-way. That’s where we would have permits or permission to be able to install those.”

As calls and messages began circulating among residents, local officials said they were trying to answer a basic question: Who, exactly, had authorized the work?

“I don’t exactly know what’s going on,” Town Supervisor Brian Walsh said on Wednesday. “I’m in the process of getting to the bottom of it.”

While Walsh said the Town of Pine Plains has no contract with Flock, he acknowledged being aware of discussions between the company and the Pine Plains Police Department months earlier, before the markings appeared.

“This whole thing started when Sgt. Beliveau was here,” Walsh said.

“We are not in contract with anybody right now.”

Walsh said the last communication he had with Flock Safety was in June.

“It was originally proposed to me as a free six-month trial,” Walsh said. “Sgt. Beliveau was heading this whole thing up. And then he obviously retired and left and moved away.”

Sgt. Michael Beliveau, a 27-year law enforcement veteran, retired from the Pine Plains Police Department following a surgery last year. The Town Board approved his resignation in July.

“I’m not in charge. I’m a sergeant. I was a contact,” Beliveau told The Herald on Friday. “I was not the one who signed the paperwork.”

Beliveau said the approval to engage with Flock came from outside of the police department. “It has to,” he said.

“We don’t have the ability, as police officers, or sergeants, or first and second in charge of the department, to make any — and I can’t emphasize enough — any decisions in that police department without running it by our bosses,” Beliveau said.

If the company installed automated license-plate reader systems at its marked locations, all vehicular traffic entering and exiting the central business district of Pine Plains could potentially be recorded. Patrick Grego / DataWrapper

On Thursday, Walsh said he had been in touch with Flock Safety. He said no Flock Safety equipment had been or would be installed.

“There are no Flock cameras going up in the town of Pine Plains,” Walsh said. “The markup was a mistake.”

Flock Safety sells surveillance cameras, drones, and automated license-plate reader systems to police departments, governments, homeowners associations, and businesses nationwide. In 2025 it was valued at $7.5 billion. Its systems typically consist of pole-mounted, solar-powered cameras that capture images of passing vehicles, convert license plates into digital data, and upload that information over cellular networks to a cloud platform. In addition to plate numbers, the system can search by what the company calls “vehicle fingerprints” — including vehicle make, model, or color — even when a plate is obscured or missing.

When asked if the Pine Plains Police Department or Town of Pine Plains had entered into an agreement with Flock Safety, Lewbel said, “I mean, it looks, you know, in my high-level thing … it looks like there was some sort of deal done. I just don’t know what it was. It’s not uncommon for Flock to work with cities and potentially have a small trial program for a city to try it out and see if it works for them.”

Walsh said he could not speak for Dutchess County or for any future plans involving county roads, including Route 83, where one of the surveillance markers appeared.

“I can’t answer for the county. I can’t answer for the future with the county,” Walsh said. “I believe there’s been discussions with the DA and the sheriff’s office on something about their crime prevention program about putting cameras up, but the town of Pine Plains is not putting cameras up.”

Two other members of the Town Board, Trevor Roush and Kevin Walsh, were unaware of any trial or plan to install surveillance cameras until contacted by the Herald. A third, Murphy Birdsall, said she had only learned about Flock from Keith Sisco.

“My immediate reaction was ICE,” Birdsall said. “Given the times, that was my reaction.”

“I sure as hell don’t want those things in Pine Plains,” Kevin Walsh said. “Even on private property, I have a problem with it because the way that it’s connected and it allows the police to use a level of surveillance that they’re not normally authorized without warrants.”

A sales representative from Flock Safety told the Herald that whoever owns the equipment is ultimately responsible for sharing, or not sharing, the data collected and stored in its cloud system.

However, a Feb. 3 report from the San Francisco Chronicle revealed that data collected from Flock Safety devices owned by the Mountain View Police Department in California was accessed by four federal agencies without the permission of the department.

“We both agreed that nothing like this will happen or will go forward in our town,” Sisco said after speaking with Brian Walsh. “Nothing like this could ever be approved unless it came before the Town Board, and unless it was something that the community was completely aware of and in support of.”

Latest News

Speed cameras gain ground in Connecticut, stall in Dutchess County

A speed enforcement camera in New York City.

Photo courtesy NYC DOT

Speed cameras remain a tough sell across northwest Connecticut — and are still absent from local roads in neighboring Dutchess County.

Town leaders across northwest Connecticut are moving cautiously on speed cameras, despite a state law passed in 2023 that allows municipalities to install them. In contrast, no towns or villages in Dutchess County currently operate local automated speed-camera programs, even as New York City has relied on the technology for years.

Keep ReadingShow less
In remembrance:
Tim Prentice and the art of making the wind visible
In remembrance: Tim Prentice and the art of making the wind visible
In remembrance: Tim Prentice and the art of making the wind visible

There are artists who make objects, and then there are artists who alter the way we move through the world. Tim Prentice belonged to the latter. The kinetic sculptor, architect and longtime Cornwall resident died in November 2025 at age 95, leaving a legacy of what he called “toys for the wind,” work that did not simply occupy space but activated it, inviting viewers to slow down, look longer and feel more deeply the invisible forces that shape daily life.

Prentice received a master’s degree from the Yale School of Art and Architecture in 1960, where he studied with German-born American artist and educator Josef Albers, taking his course once as an undergraduate and again in graduate school.In “The Air Made Visible,” a 2024 short film by the Vision & Art Project produced by the American Macular Degeneration Fund, a nonprofit organization that documents artists working with vision loss, Prentice spoke of his admiration for Albers’ discipline and his ability to strip away everything but color. He recalled thinking, “If I could do that same thing with motion, I’d have a chance of finding a new form.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Strategic partnership unites design, architecture and construction

Hyalite Builders is leading the structural rehabilitation of The Stissing Center in Pine Plains.

Provided

For homeowners overwhelmed by juggling designers, architects and contractors, a new Salisbury-based collaboration is offering a one-team approach from concept to construction. Casa Marcelo Interior Design Studio, based in Salisbury, has joined forces with Charles Matz Architect, led by Charles Matz, AIA RIBA, and Hyalite Builders, led by Matt Soleau. The alliance introduces an integrated design-build model that aims to streamline the sometimes-fragmented process of home renovation and new construction.

“The whole thing is based on integrated services,” said Marcelo, founder of Casa Marcelo. “Normally when clients come to us, they are coming to us for design. But there’s also some architecture and construction that needs to happen eventually. So, I thought, why don’t we just partner with people that we know we can work well with together?”

Keep ReadingShow less