Will Guidara’s dreams for Second Mountain at Migdale

Will Guidara’s dreams for Second Mountain at Migdale
Will Guidara Photo submitted

MILLBROOK — At the Town of Washington’s (TOW) Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) meeting in March, NYC restaurateur Will Guidara (the applicant behind Janet Farm, LLC and the Second Mountain project to redo the Migdale estate in Mabbettsville) rescinded his petition for a Zoning Overlay District on the property’s 350-plus acres of land because he said there was too much opposition and he wants to be a good neighbor. Since then, people have been curious. They’ve wanted to know more about Guidara and his plans.

Many in the Millbrook community wonder what the outcome of the application for this rather controversial hotel and spa development will be, and whether or not the proposal will be allowed to go forward. There are two groups in the community — one of adjacent neighbors and one of nearby residents and other community members who are staunchly against it, who have expressed concerns about traffic congestion, problems with water and sewage and complaints that the development is in opposition to the town’s comprehensive plan.  

This newspaper has spoken with others in town who have said they believe the Second Mountain project would be a good thing for Millbrook, but those people thus far have kept quiet in public, bearing in mind that more than 200 residents have signed a petition against it. 

 

What is planned

The application, as outlined by Guidara during a number of presentations before the town in the past couple of months, would take the historic Migdale property and convert it into a luxury hotel with two restaurants: one high end and one less formal. He also is planning to include new cabins, cottages and rental units, perhaps condos. Amenities including an outdoor theater, hiking trails, tennis courts, swimming pools and a spa have been mentioned, and the thought of the additional traffic the development could cause and the added pressure it could add to the town’s water and sewer systems have raised some hackles. 

Sticking points

The main complaint raised by opponents is that the project doesn’t fit in with the town’s Comprehensive Plan, completed in 2015. That vision includes the Millbrook community remaining rural, “with great scenic beauty.” 

The comprehensive plan goes on to state that the town will protect, among other things, water resources and natural habitats. On page 37 of the Comprehensive Plan, in its vision statement, the town states it believes in “maintaining a vibrant and diverse local business district, while maintaining the character, the look and the feel of the community.”

There have been complaints that Millbrook’s business district is less than vibrant today than in years past, of several businesses that have quickly come and gone, of a number of long-established businesses that have closed and of high retail prices. Those concerns have been met by merchants who reply with complaints of high commercial rents.  

The issues are likely  heard all across the country,  and are encouraging some in the town to suggest that it’s time to bring more innovative enterprises into the community to generate revenue. 

Guidara’s dream

The developer has said he is willing to make some concessions to his original plans to appease the community. While an outdoor theater was mentioned in one presentation, Guidara clarified in an interview with this newspaper this month that he is not envisioning something like the Four Brothers Drive-In Theatre in Amenia. Rather, he said, neighbors should envision the type of screen one might install in “your own backyard.”

Far from wanting to destroy the quaintness and beauty of Millbrook, Guidara said he is looking forward to moving onto the property with his wife and 6-week-old daughter, Frankie. 

They currently live in Kingston, where they bought a house six years ago. They moved there  full-time last year when the pandemic began, shortly after he and his business partner, chef Daniel Humm, dissolved their partnership. The two had great success with the Make It Nice hospitality group, which owned Eleven Madison Park, and several Michelin-rated NoMad restaurants around the country.

Guidara and his wife decided to settle in the area and find a location for the Second Mountain project. Migdale, in Mabbettsville, where the property is set back from the road, was perfect, he said.  He doesn’t plan to build anything taller than one story on the property; the only exception will be the main house, which is already standing. He said he already spoke to the Millbrook fire department and several other local residents and businesses about his intentions.

Guidara said he feels Second Mountain will be a vacation destination, and that his clientele will bring their dollars to other businesses in the village and town. He plans to coordinate with Orvis Sandanona on their Gaming Weekends, the Millbrook Vineyards, Trevor Zoo, Innisfree Garden and many other attractions in the Hudson Valley and Tri-state region.

A business owner’s thoughts

Danielle Molello, owner of Blue Dragonfly Body Works in Millbrook, said she thinks the project could be positive for the community, but doesn’t think local residents have been well informed about the plans. She’d like more public meetings, like those held when the village was deciding what to do with the Thorne Building on Franklin Avenue, where residents asked questions and made comments. Molello feels that there is a lack of information and that the project seems “separate,” much like the Silo Ridge Field Club in nearby Amenia. 

“It would help a great deal to get community involvement in knowing what is going on, what the plans are,” she said. “As a business owner, potential clientele is always welcome, and many of the other business owners may feel the same way. An influx of new blood may be just what the village needs. One person pointed out that Silo Ridge may have hired a lot of non-local help, but some of those workers moved here, adding taxpayers to tax rolls and students to the local school districts.”

Willing to compromise

Guidara and his legal team pulled their petition for the Overlay District, but he said he still intends to pursue his dream. His plans have evolved, he said, and because he’s taking a personal approach his ideas are also evolving. 

He said he wants to work with both town officials and residents to make Second Mountain happen. He recognizes it will take time and not happen overnight. 

Because he will be “a neighbor,” Guidara said he doesn’t want to alienate other potential neighbors in the town and village, and while he has a lot invested in the project, in traffic studies, lawyers’ fees and environmental studies, he wants to do things properly.

Guidara said he is waiting to take the next step, although there is no confirmation on exactly what that will be, while the town is currently studying its comprehensive plan. 

Latest News

Washington officials eye improvements to town pool

The Washington town pool in the hamlet of Mabbetsville along Route 44 sits ready for the start of the 2026 season.

Photo By Graham Corrigan

MILLBROOK — Members of the Washington Town Board are calling for upgrades to the town’s recreation area in Mabbetsville along Route 44, saying the park’s roughly 80-year-old pool is outdated and increasingly difficult to maintain.

Former Washington Councilmember Mike Murphy presented a new report to the Town Board during its regular meeting on Wednesday, May 13, detailing the needed updates to the park.

Keep ReadingShow less

Local volunteers

Local volunteers

Enhancing educational opportunities for students in the Millbrook Central School District since 2001, the Millbrook Educational Foundation took part in the Millbrook Volunteer Fair on Saturday, May 16. Residents were invited to learn about volunteer opportunities with the foundation and a variety of other local and regional organizations. The event, now in its fifth year, was held at the Millbrook Library.

North East home prices hold steady while sales activity slows

Known as the “Ice House,” 12 State Line Road on 3.81 acres was sold by the mortgage holder after standing vacant for years. The property was later renovated and resold for $400,000 on April 15.

Photo by Christine Bates

MILLERTON — North East’s housing market continued to cool this spring, with home prices holding relatively steady and sales activity slowing compared with the post-pandemic surge that drove prices sharply higher across the region.

The 12-month trailing median sale price for residential properties in the Town of North East, including the Village of Millerton, was $420,000 for the period from May 1, 2025, through April 30, 2026. That figure remained essentially unchanged month-to-month, but marked the second consecutive year of declining annual median prices.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Innisfree Garden to host annual Spring Community Day

MILLBROOK — Innisfree Garden is set to welcome northeast Dutchess residents for its annual Spring Community Day.

The beloved community event returns Saturday, May 23 — with free admission for residents of Millerton, North East, Amenia, Wassaic, Pine Plains, Clinton Corners, Dover Plains, Pleasant Valley, Stanford, Wingdale, Washington, and of course, Millbrook. Visitors seeking free admission must present identification showing residency in one of the listed towns or hamlets.

Keep ReadingShow less
New home a ‘blessing’ for Millerton family after home evacuation

Tim Watson sits in his living room that used to serve as a waiting area for a dentist’s office on Route 44 in Millerton.

Photo by Nathan Miller

MILLERTON — More than three months after a malfunctioning furnace forced the Watson family from their Main Street apartment, Tim Watson said life is finally beginning to stabilize.

The Watsons were tenants of 7-9 Main St. on Jan. 31 when a malfunctioning furnace filled the apartment building with carbon monoxide, forcing emergency responders to evacuate the building. Authorities ruled the building unsafe after the emergency and it has remained vacant since. The Dutchess County Supreme Court granted a foreclosure to US Bancorp for the property in late March.

Keep ReadingShow less
Amenia Housing Board to submit potential uses for remaining $13K in grant funds
Amenia Town Hall on Route 22.
Photo by Nathan Miller

AMENIA — Housing Board members agreed on three potential uses for remaining grant funds, moving a step toward utilizing the money that was leftover from a Foundation for Community Health grant.

Board members voted on Monday, May 11, to draft a report for FCH detailing three initiatives for the leftover $13,000 aimed at clarifying local housing regulations, defining the board’s responsibilities related to the Housing Trust Fund, and expanding resources for residents seeking to create accessory dwelling units.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.