Amenia seeks dismissal of alleged contract zoning suit

Amenia seeks dismissal of alleged contract zoning suit
The main entrance to Kent Hollow Mine at 341 South Amenia Road in Amenia.
Photo by Nathan Miller

AMENIA — Attorneys for the Town of Amenia have moved to dismiss a lawsuit challenging a settlement agreement that allows Kent Hollow Inc., a local sand and gravel company, to resume limited mining operations once it obtains the required state mining permit.

The agreement, approved by the Town Board in April 2025, recognizes Kent Hollow’s nonconforming use rights on its South Amenia Road property — rights that have been the subject of years of litigation between the town and the mine’s owners.

The current lawsuit — filed by residents Laurence Levin and Theodore Schiffman, along with Wassaic-based construction company Clark Hill LLC — claims the agreement constitutes unlawful “contract zoning,” arguing that the town bargained away its zoning authority in exchange for ending years of litigation brought by Kent Hollow in both state and federal courts.

In the motion seeking dismissal, the town argues that a failure to name the Amenia Zoning Board of Appeals and other individuals involved in the case constituted a fatal error in the filing.

“If the relief sought by Petitioners is granted and the Settlement Agreement is annulled, all of those individuals would not only be forced to incur the cost of defending themselves in that litigation, but could be jointly and severally liable for any damages that result,” Attorney George Lithco wrote in a memorandum in support of the motion to dismiss.

The town’s memorandum further argues that the plaintiffs misunderstand the terms of the settlement, which underwent judicial review before adoption and, according to Lithco, affirms the mine’s nonconforming rights.

The petitioners, however, contend that a prior court ruling did not make such a determination, arguing that the judge declined to decide on the mine’s zoning status and instead focused on whether members of the Zoning Board of Appeals and the Town Board had an unethical conflict of interest.

Town attorneys counter that the judicially reviewed settlement itself reflects acknowledgment of those rights.

Latest News

‘STOP ICE’ billboard turns heads in North East

A provocative new billboard on Route 22 in the Town of North East appears to bear a political message but is actually an ad for a local paving company.

Photo by Nathan Miller

MILLERTON — A billboard located in North East recently received a new advertisement, and the message is catching drivers’ attention.

At first glance, the billboard appears to convey a political message. In large capital letters, it reads, “STOP ICE.” But in much smaller type below, the sign clarifies its real pitch: “from filling your driveway potholes next winter — pave it. Call Ben.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Planning Board grants 12-month extension for Stissing Center renovations

Patrick Trettenero, Stissing Center Executive Director, displays a photo of the current state of the music and performing arts venue’s renovations at a regular meeting of the Pine Plains Planning Board on Wednesday, March 11.

Photo by Nathan Miller

PINE PLAINS — Planning Board members approved a second renewal for ongoing renovations to the Stissing Center, an arts venue in downtown Pine Plains.

Board members granted a 12-month renewal of the Stissing Center’s site plan, allowing the project to continue while construction moves forward. Planning board approvals typically expire after a set period if projects are not completed, requiring applicants to request extensions while work continues.

Keep ReadingShow less
North East Community Center Executive Director steps down after 8 years

The building that housed the North East Community Center’s Early Learning Program in Millerton. The program closed last November due to financial difficulties, a decision that drew criticism from parents and staff and preceded the recent departure of Executive Director Christine Sergent.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

MILLERTON – The North East Community Center announced that Christine Sergent, who has served as the organization’s executive director for eight years, left her position as of Friday, March 13. Staff were notified on Friday shortly before a statement was sent to the community.

Board Chair Irene Banning said she and the board accepted Sergent’s resignation, but would not elaborate on the timing or circumstances surrounding the departure. Sergent was removed from the website’s staff page as of Friday evening.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Rural towns plagued by slow EMS response times

Dutchess County Emergency Medical Services Commissioner William Beale addresses the County Legislature's Public Safety Committee during a meeting in Poughkeepsie on Wednesday, March 4.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

Ambulance response times to life-threatening emergencies in parts of northeastern Dutchess County were among the slowest in the county last year, according to newly released county data. Region 5, which includes Amenia, Dover, North East and the Village of Millerton, ranked last among the county’s seven EMS regions for the percentage of life-threatening calls reached within nine minutes — a benchmark widely used to measure acceptable response times.

The poor ranking comes even after Dutchess County spent roughly $4 million over two years on a supplemental emergency medical service program intended to improve coverage and response times.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Maple Syrup Madness’ draws visitors to Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo for sweet treats

Dan Cohen, left, dispenses whipped cream on a plate of maple syrup treats during a demonstration on the making of maple syrup at Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo on Millbrook School’s campus.

Photos by Aly Morrissey

MILLBROOK — The Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo hosted its sixth annual Maple Syrup Madness Weekend on March 7 and 8, drawing visitors eager to sample fresh maple syrup, learn about the sugaring process and enjoy one of the region’s sweetest seasonal activities. The event will continue March 14 and 15, as long as the sap continues to flow, organizers said.

Visitors were treated to free tastings of locally made maple syrup with a side of waffles, while Alan Tousignant — a woodworker, syrup maker and director of the Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo — led demonstrations showing how sap collected from nearby maple trees is transformed into syrup.

Keep ReadingShow less
Stolen stroller returned to owner after grassroots recovery effort

Relief Chiropractic and Wellness on South Center Street in the Village of Millerton, where a stroller was reported stolen and later returned after Tyler Van Steenbergen

MILLERTON — News of a stolen stroller swept through Millerton last week after a grassroots effort to recover the expensive baby equipment gained traction on Main Street and social media.

The stroller, an UPPAbaby Vista model — widely considered a high-end brand and valued at more than $1,000 — was taken from outside Relief Chiropractic and Wellness on the corner of Main Street and South Center Street before it was anonymously returned the following day.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.