The evil do-gooders do

A View From the Edge; Thursday, Nov. 14, 2024

Joseph Conrad always saw accurately into the heart of man, understood the real hidden danger was always in the well-meaning do-gooder, a person so myopic that they do not realize the dangers, the evils, they pose. And so it has proved, with well-meaning do-gooders (and some ringers) in Arizona, Missouri, Maryland, Montana, Nevada, New York, Colorado, Florida, Nebraska and South Dakota.

In those states, there were urgent additions to the ballots putting forth state constitutional amendments to protect a woman’s right to choose. That seemed both moral and right. What was terribly wrong was that this gave people who would otherwise have had to vote for a just President (to protect women’s rights) a convenient escape for personal preference: they could try or pretend to try to protect women’s rights yet still vote for the very person responsible for this terrible law. In short, people went into the election booth, ticked the box pretending to protect women’s rights at the state level, while still voting for the very fascist who took them away and has vowed, crowed with pride, at having done so.

And the farce does not stop there. What they achieved in Arizona, Missouri, Maryland, Montana, Nevada, New York, Colorado, and failed in Florida, Nebraska and South Dakota is nothing. Not a damn thing.

Federal law has Constitutional priority over state law. Even if every state “protected” women’s rights, a federal ban — as promised in Project 2025, now re-labeled as Maga Playbook 180 (which clearly shows they mean to enforce Project 2025 measures in 180 days) — a federal abortion ban wipes out every state law, every single State Constitutional ballot measure. Poof, finito. And MAGA is already putting that before Congress.

So, in the end, these well-meaning women’s rights groups have played into Maga’s election hands. And with their do-gooderism, in this one election goes the future of our Constitution and, sadly, world peace.

Peter Riva, a former resident of Amenia Union, now lives in New Mexico

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Millerton News and The News does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Low Road Sharon hearing extended

The Sharon Town Hall was packed for the Low Road hearing on Wednesday, Aug. 13.

Alec Linden

SHARON — It was standing room only Wednesday, Aug. 13, for the second round of public hearing for an application by arts nonprofit Low Road Sharon to develop an office space and events facility adjacent to the North Main Street shopping plaza.

Land Surveyor James McTigue of Arthur H. Howland & Associates and Conley Rollins representing the nonprofit presented changes to the proposal since the last hearing. The alterations were made in response to queries from residents and officials alike for more specific plans for the usage of the site and clarification on development specifications such as lighting, parking and landscaping.

Keep ReadingShow less
New Mabbetsville farm store opens for year-round operation

Amenia native Holly Hammond shows off a few heirloom tomatoes in her new farm store, The General’s Gathering, in Mabbetsville.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

MILLBROOK — Nestled along Route 44 in Mabbetsville, The General’s Gathering is a new farm store in Dutchess County that’s quickly becoming a one-stop-shop for farm-fresh products. Open Thursday through Sunday from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., The General’s Gathering offers everything from maple syrup and packaged goods to bread, meat, eggs and fresh harvest — all locally sourced.

With a robust lineup of local labels and vendors, The General’s Gathering is filling a void along Route 44 between Litchfield and Dutchess Counties. Shoppers can find products from Great Cape, Ronnybrook Farm, Sterling Bake Shop, and more — with in-store staples complemented by seasonal outdoor vendors in a farmer’s market style.

Keep ReadingShow less
Local schools implement ‘bell-to-bell’ cellphone bans

AMENIA — The Webutuck School District is implementing a bell-to-bell cellphone ban in the wake of new York State legislation requiring public schools to create a “distraction-free” environment.

At Webutuck, students will be required to store cellphones in their lockers during the day, where the devices are to remain unused until the final bell at the day’s end.

Keep ReadingShow less
School supply drive accepting applications until Aug. 22

AMENIA — The grassroots group Harlem Valley Compassion Connection is conducting a school supply drive aiding students in the Webutuck and Dover school districts.

This year’s drive is the most recent in a nearly decade-long effort led by a group of Dover and Amenia residents, and the fourth since Harlem Valley Compassion Connection officially organized as a 501(c)3 in 2021, organizer Maryalyce Merritt of Wassaic said.

Keep ReadingShow less