Pine Plains Platter to shut down for good

Community heartbroken over closure

Pine Plains Platter to shut down for good
Located on Church Street (Route 199) next to Peck’s Market, many customers will be sad to say goodbye to one of their favorite community hubs, the Pine Plains Platter, when it shuts down on Sunday, Sept. 26.
Photo by Kaitlin Lyle

PINE PLAINS — For many local residents as well as visitors to Pine Plains, the thought of driving into town one day and seeing the Pine Plains Platter permanently closed seems unimaginable, given how the cafe has flourished these last few years as a hub for the community, not to mention a place to get some great home cooking. Yet to the disappointment of practically everyone — The Platter’s owners/landlords, its manager and staff and its clientele, that thought will soon become a reality as the business is going to shutdown for good come Sunday, Sept. 26.

Established at 2987 Church St. (Route 199), next to Peck’s Market, The Platter is housed on the street level of a building owned by Jack and Irene Banning, who purchased it in 2012. While the pair owns The Platter, it’s been run for the past few years by the very competent Christina Smith-Hedges, who had hopes of taking over the business. 

“Our aim always was to provide a platform for some entrepreneur who would come in and manage the restaurant for us and become in a position to purchase the business then take over the lease and that’s what we hoped would happen,” Jack Banning said. 

Over time, The Platter gained a following from the local and weekend communities. When the COVID-19 pandemic hit, Smith-Hedges said she and her staff did everything they possibly could to adapt, following all the safety rules and even picking up catering orders. 

However, after spending the last several months trying to figure out how to keep operations moving forward, Banning realized they reached a point where it wasn’t going to work out anymore and they had to pull the plug.

“This was obviously a tough decision all around: terribly disappointing for Cris, terribly disappointing for us and terribly disappointing for all of our customers,” Banning said. “The story from our perspective is that this is something we felt we had to do at this time.”

The business decision was especially difficult for Smith-Hedges, who had planned to purchase the building from the Bannings this fall. She said she’d gone into a meeting with Jack thinking it would be to talk about her purchasing the building. Instead, she said he rescinded the offer, saying The Platter was barely sustaining itself through the pandemic and that he didn’t see things getting any better.

Banning explained he and Irene had conversations with Smith-Hedges and thought they might be able to structure an arrangement to save the cafe. 

Attributing their decision to a combination of factors, he said they looked at the finances, what options were available to Smith-Hedges and what her skill sets were and determined there was no viable way to make the business succeed. Though the Bannings suggested The Platter close the week of Friday, Oct. 1, Smith-Hedges decided the Platter would close on Sunday, Sept. 26.

Notifying The Platter’s employees of the closure, Banning said they provided everyone with five weeks’ notice with the expectation that they’d provide generous compensation. 

Smith-Hedges said it’s now a guessing game, knowing how short-staffed she currently is. So far, The Platter’s hours of operation have been reduced and the menu is limited.

Catching on to the news of The Platter’s imminent closing, customers have said they are heartbroken at the thought of their favorite local cafe shutting down. Many have posted on social media their disappointment, others have contacted this newspaper.

“This is heartbreaking for the employees, a tremendous loss for the town and a special blow to weekenders who have only this one place to eat on Sundays,” said Pine Plains resident Matt Finley.

“In this ever-changing world with much pain and uncertainty… we want to thank you, Cris, and your incredible team for creating this magical place in our community and in my life,” said Santina Tirone, another loyal customer. “Your open arms, warmth and not to mention the incredible fresh local menu with be tragically missed.”

Come Sunday, Sept. 26, at 10 a.m., Smith-Hedges said The Platter will hold a Peace Out Platter Party. As a token of her seven years at The Platter, she said she bought a book to compile all of the pictures under the table and the sticky notes customers have left there.

“Basically, the love I put into this place, I’m taking with me when I leave,” Smith-Hedges said, “so the last day is going to be a hard day… honestly, I’m still upset … but I’ve made peace with the decision.”

Yet this might not be the end for the cafe as Banning said he and Irene want something to continue in that space that’s “viable and provides the kind of environment that we think is right for this space. The Platter will survive in some incarnation. We’re hopeful. We’re sad obviously, but we’re hopeful.”

Latest News

‘Maple Syrup Madness’ draws visitors to Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo for sweet treats

Dan Cohen, left, dispenses whipped cream on a plate of maple syrup treats during a demonstration on the making of maple syrup at Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo on Millbrook School’s campus.

Photos by Aly Morrissey

MILLBROOK — The Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo hosted its sixth annual Maple Syrup Madness Weekend on March 7 and 8, drawing visitors eager to sample fresh maple syrup, learn about the sugaring process and enjoy one of the region’s sweetest seasonal activities. The event will continue March 14 and 15, as long as the sap continues to flow, organizers said.

Visitors were treated to free tastings of locally made maple syrup with a side of waffles, while Alan Tousignant — a woodworker, syrup maker and director of the Trevor-Lovejoy Zoo — led demonstrations showing how sap collected from nearby maple trees is transformed into syrup.

Keep ReadingShow less

Accuracy and reputation key to local news

Accuracy and reputation key to local news

Publisher James Clark, left, and Executive Editor Christian Murray speak at Scoville Memorial Library March 7.

Photo by Patrick L. Sullivan

SALISBURY — What makes or breaks a local newspaper is its reputation, Lakeville Journal Executive Editor Christian Murray said at the Scoville Memorial Library Saturday, March 7.

Murray and publisher James Clark led a discussion at the library that was originally scheduled for January, but the weather intervened.

Keep ReadingShow less
Library building expected to reopen one month after burst pipe floods basement

The Millerton fire crew watches a pump hose carry water from the NorthEast-Millerton Library’s basement on Tuesday, Feb. 10.

Photo by Nathan Miller

MILLERTON — Library officials expect the NorthEast-Millerton Library to be fully open the weekend of March 14-15, a full month after a burst pipe forced librarians to move operations to the annex building on Century Boulevard.

Executive Director Rhiannon Leo-Jameson said the temporary relocation has been stressful, but library patrons have been understanding and using the library to the fullest extent possible.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Alfred Lyon Ivry

Alfred Lyon Ivry

SALISBURY — Alfred Lyon Ivry, a long-time resident of Salisbury, and son of Belle (Malamud) and Morris Ivry, died in Bergen County, New Jersey, on Feb. 12 at the age of 91, surrounded by family members. Born and raised in Brooklyn, he was a graduate ofAbraham Lincoln High School and Brooklyn College, where he earned a B.A. in English literature and Philosophy and served as drama critic for the school paper.

Alfred earned a PhD in Medieval Jewish Philosophy from Brandeis University in Waltham, Massachusetts in 1963 and in 1971 was awarded a D. Phil in Medieval Islamic Philosophy from Oxford University, Linacre College.

Keep ReadingShow less

Larry Power

Larry Power

LAKEVILLE — Larry Power passed away peacefully at home on March 9, 2026.

Larry was born at St. Vincent’s Hospital in New York City in 1939.

Keep ReadingShow less

Carol Hoffman Matzke

Carol Hoffman Matzke

KENT — Carol L. Hoffman Matzke passed away peacefully with family by her side on Feb. 22, 2026.

She was a beloved mother and stepmother, daughter, sister, grandmother, great-grandmother, community member, and friend.Her presence will be deeply missed. She had a beautiful way of loving, accepting, and supporting all the many members of her vast family, and of welcoming others into her family circle. She was intelligent and well-informed about history and current events, and she took a genuine interest in knowing and understanding everyone she met, from friends and family right down to the stranger who stood next to her in line at the grocery store. Kind and generous, her family and friends knew that she would do anything in her power to help and support them.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.