The upshot of medicinal labels

For centuries, in a sincere effort to categorize illness to affect a better treatment, the medical industry has developed a system of labels to identify illness and medical conditions. And, yes, over the past century, many of the historic labels have been dropped and ridiculed — for good reason. Some of these defunct labels have a pernicious, damaging, past.

Take a label that was accepted by the psychiatric community until 1990: Homosexuality. There are cases of electroshock therapy for this diagnosis and label — all too common.

A hundred years ago there was a common diagnosis of “feeblemindedness,” which covered all sorts of illnesses, injuries and birth conditions.

Treatment for feeblemindedness? From this label, people applied new theories such as Eugenics, the erroneous and immoral theory of “racial improvement” and “planned breeding.”

In today’s business of medicine, labeling allows for instant identification of the right drug, the prescription of patent medicine to expediently assume proper treatment and a generalization of a patient’s outcome, which is devoid of personalization and often leads to complications and side effects hammering small groups of patent drug takers.

The lawyers, to stem financial loss, force commercials to list “possible” side-effects all the way from rashes to horrible death. It is worth remembering those side-effects are listed because they are known to have happened to someone, somewhere. And let’s not forget that doctors for the asbestos industries were paid to hide the dangers, as were the doctors working in and around the cigarette industries.

But a new breed of doctors is seeing labeling as the opposite of patient care. Faced with the commercial reality of a demand for promises of a cure (if you have “X” and get prescribed “Y,” you can have certainty toward recovery), they now probe deeper, taking the time to delve into individual patent’s ailments and causes of illness that often allows for better long-term treatment.

As one doctor explained on a Swiss radio show, “My patients are conditioned to want to know what exactly is wrong. They want a label.”

He went on to say he sometimes makes up a name and sets about finding a treatment protocol, which usually includes a 30-day convalescence.

“The rest, for many patients, allows the body to stabilize, makes minor drug administration more effective and, above all, gives greater hope than simply a pat on the back and a handful of prescriptions.”

Part of the problem with labeling is that the government has gotten involved — sometimes not for the better. If you can’t, for example, get a formal medical diagnosis of PTSD or ADHD, you can’t qualify for financial assistance or special schooling.

If you are sad, truly sad, and cannot handle the stress of not being up to par for work, only a doctor’s diagnosis and label of “depression” along with suitable drugs, can qualify you with medical bills and allow leave from work.

Remember, medical evaluation and medical expertise individually assessed and overseen is always the best route to take. The pitfalls come from the labels used that may — or may not — add to the stress for the patient trying to navigate insurance companies, government assistance and employers’ sick leave criteria.

Diagnosis should not become the necessary key, the only acceptable label, for support and common sense.

 

Peter Riva, a former resident of Amenia Union, now resides in New Mexico.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Millerton News and The News does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Vitsky Bakery turns local surplus into seasonal pastries
Ariel Yotive portions out dough for baked goods to be sold at Vitsky Bakery in Wassaic. Yotive has been baking since she was a child helping in her father’s Illinois-based Quality Bakery.
Langdon Speers

WASSAIC — Ariel Yotive has a motto, “Work with what you’ve got.” Her unique Vitsky Bakery in Wassaic has the fruits of that motivation flying off the shelves.

Literally, during apricot season, one of her neighboring farm orchards may be harvesting fresh-off-the-tree fruit that is transformed into danishes. Local hives supply honey for Cream Buns with White Chocolate or a Ricotta Custard with a chunk of honeycomb floating in the middle. “I use what is around,” said the baker.

Keep ReadingShow less
Severe flu season strains hospitals, schools, care facilities across the region

Dr. Mark Marshall, an internist at Sharon Hospital, said, “The statistics suggest it’s the worst flu season in 30 years.”

Photo by Bridget Starr Taylor

A severe and fast-moving flu season is straining health care systems on both sides of the state line, with Connecticut and New York reporting “very high” levels of respiratory illness activity.

Hospitals, schools and clinics are seeing a surge in influenza cases—a trend now being felt acutely across the Northwest Corner.

Keep ReadingShow less
Demonstrators in Salisbury call for justice, accountability

Ed Sheehy and Tom Taylor of Copake, New York, and Karen and Wendy Erickson of Sheffield, Massachusetts, traveled to Salisbury on Saturday to voice their anger with the Trump administration.

Photo by Alec Linden

SALISBURY — Impassioned residents of the Northwest Corner and adjacent regions in Massachusetts and New York took to the Memorial Green Saturday morning, Jan. 10, to protest the recent killing of Minneapolis resident Renee Nicole Good at the hands of a federal immigration agent.

Good, a 37-year-old mother of three, was shot at close range by an officerwith Immigration and Customs Enforcement, commonly known as ICE, on Wednesday, Jan. 7. She and her wife were participating in a protest opposing the agency’s presence in a Minneapolis neighborhood at the time of the shooting.

Keep ReadingShow less
Northern Dutchess Paramedics remains in service amid changes at Sharon Hospital

Area ambulance squad members, along with several first selectmen, attend a Jan. 5 meeting on emergency service providers hosted by Nuvance/Northwell.

Photo by Ruth Epstein

FALLS VILLAGE, Conn. — Paramedic coverage in the Northwest Corner is continuing despite concerns raised last month after Sharon Hospital announced it would not renew its long-standing sponsorship agreement with Northern Dutchess Paramedics.

Northern Dutchess Paramedics (NDP), which has provided advanced life support services in the region for decades, is still responding to calls and will now operate alongside a hospital-based paramedic service being developed by Sharon Hospital, officials said at a public meeting Monday, Jan. 5, at the Falls Village Emergency Services Center.

Keep ReadingShow less