Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

A history lesson relevant to today: Loss of choice mirrors WWII

Until the last 40 years, most families always supplemented their food with hunting. Pre-World War II, there were less than 2 billion people on the planet (today there are 7 billion-plus). Hunting and the wildlife food supply were a normal, regular, habitual part of families’ lives. Disrupting that often meant families went hungry. In fact, after World War I, as part of the Versailles Treaty, Germany was forced to restrict gun ownership for its citizens in case they were arming themselves for more war. Many families, especially the poorer ones, had trouble feeding themselves and it helped lead to their Recession.

In 1938, the Nazis relaxed all these gun laws, especially the right to bear arms, citing individual liberty and pandering to families’ needs for traditional hunting for food. These traditional rights to hunt, to kill and slaughter animals for sport and food, were fundamental to that country’s way of life. You could say they were so fundamental they could be said, in American terms, to be constitutional, inalienable, grandfathered.

However, the party in control then used those rights as leverage to divide the country further. One part of German society was deemed to be unfit to share those traditional, cultural, moral rights. Jews were identified as “dirty” and “having big noses” and had to wear a yellow star badge to identify their so-called race. Once identified as non-Aryan (meaning not real humans), this portion of society quickly saw those Nazi open gun laws being amended to say that non-Aryans could not obtain, make, sell or own “dangerous weapons,” which included guns, shotguns and hunting rifles.

Now, many might say that taking away someone’s traditional gun rights is a small issue, even if only a portion of society — the Jews — felt the impact. Until the nights of Nov. 9 and 10, 1938, when an ATF (Germany equivalent) gun raid was held to confiscate and arrest any Jews and Jewish family members (kids and all) in possession of firearms: Kristallnacht, the turning point in the history of the Third Reich, marking the shift from antisemitic rhetoric and legislation to the violent, aggressive anti-Jewish measures that would culminate with the Holocaust.

America is on the cusp of such division and legislation, judges who swore and gave testimony that Roe v. Wade was precedent under law, and the “law of the land,” have decided to perjure themselves morally and perhaps legally to spin-off protection, traditional and constitutional protection, and to defy the morals and majority of the electorate’s wishes.

Make no mistake here. The legal subject of Roe v. Wade may have been abortion, but the issue, the constitutional issue, was about liberty and equal rights under the Constitution for all Americans.

A woman’s right to choose is her liberty in life, guaranteed by the Constitution, not a political party. In the same way in 1938 that changing Jews’ right to equally bear arms as the rest of the German citizenry could lead to division, terror and mass murder, so too will what seems like as small a subject as abortion lead to a denial of equal rights, equal liberty and the destruction of the fundamentals of our Constitution and decency in America.

Germany’s legal system enabled the Nazi party’s rise to power, enabled the concentration camps, helped re-write legal definitions of Aryan, proportionality Aryan (Mischlinge) and non-Aryan, upheld Nazi-era laws of discrimination of cripples, the mentally ill, Gypsies, homosexuality, out-of-wedlock births — the list is long and tortured. Hitler didn’t do all this himself. The forces behind his power base, those who came out in support of “real Germans” versus others, those enablers and sycophants, numbered in their thousands.

Not all Germans felt that way, but then the Nazi party didn’t need all Germans, just about 40% in their Make-Germany-great-again party who were willing to go to absolute ends. For Germany, the 40% started with authoritarian fixers, judges, politicians, duped common people and rich media backers. It ended with 104,812 U.S. soldiers dying to stop the Nazis in Europe alone. Total dead from the Nazis? It was 40 million to 50 million in Europe alone.

We know there are 40% here in the USA who seem determined to strip liberty from citizens they disagree with, who see many of their fellow citizens as unworthy to be real Americans either by race, creed, color or sexual orientation. This 40% power base uses religious non-scientific beliefs on pregnancy as weapons to whip up impassioned support for the one issue, using it as a Trojan Horse for their real aims of control. Many of their party speak openly of wanting to remove constitutional rights for marriage (interracial and inter-sexual), force identification of “real” Americans for voting rights, restrict poor regions from equal voting access, claim that our Republic should only allow states to set their own laws, not federally, and, never least, claim that Washington is “apart from the real America” all the while using democratic laws and the D.C. power base to further their aims to wrest control from the People for their own ends.

Does all of this sound familiar? History always repeats unless educated people prevent the same errors reoccurring. The Roe v. Wade greater issue is not about pregnancy or abortion, it is about a fight for our Constitution, liberty and individual rights. To fail now to defend the Constitution turns the clock back to 1938, only this time it is our nation’s corruption that could lead us down a very dark path.

Peter Riva, a former resident of Amenia Union, now lives in New Mexico.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Millerton News and The News does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Shaping the future of Amenia’s recreation planning

Tiffany Zezula, deputy director of the Pace Land Use Law Center of White Plains, presents early results of a survey of Amenia residents on their desires for local parks and recreation during a forum at Webutuck High School on Saturday, June 13. Residents were invited to hear a preliminary report on the ongoing study sponsored by the Parks and Recreation Commission to assist with charting the future of recreation and parks in Amenia.

Photo By Leila Hawken

AMENIA — Residents would like to see more amenities, programming and access at Amenia’s parks and recreational sites, according to preliminary results from a town recreation survey presented Saturday, June 13.

A status report was presented at the Webutuck High School auditorium on Saturday, June 13, by Engaging Amenia planning consultants from Pace Land Use Law Center of White Plains.

Keep ReadingShow less
Parking rules a hurdle for proposed Millerton apartments

MILLERTON — Plans for new apartments on South Center Street are facing uncertainty over parking regulations in the Village of Millerton.

The buildings have a total of four apartments located at 26-32 South Center St, though only three have been occupied in recent years. Owner Alex Magalhaes described plans to renovate the interior of the building and utilize the empty unit.

Keep ReadingShow less

Flea market seeks local vendors

Flea market seeks local vendors

MILLERTON — The North East/Millerton Climate Smart Task Force is seeking participants for a community-wide flea market set to coincide with Millerton’s 175th celebration.

The community-wide flea market will run throughout Millerton, with Eddie Collins Memorial Park serving as a central hub. Spaces at the park are available or sellers can run a sale at their own homes.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Self-storage and farm market plans move forward

PINE PLAINS — The Planning Board unanimously approved the environmental review for a proposed storage facility expansion and farm stand at 2818 Church St. during its meeting Wednesday, June 10.

The property, located across from the high school, would expand the neighboring Stissing Storage business. Steve Hobson of HTWO Properties presented updated site plans that include additional storage units at the rear of the lot and a free-standing farm stand near the road.

Keep ReadingShow less
Summer art opening shows off talent at The Fountains

Artistic talent is on display at the Fountains’ Summer Art Show, which opened Thursday, June 11. The exhibition features works by several residents and drew a strong turnout of artists and guests, who were welcomed on opening day by art instructor Ellen O’Shea.

Photo By Leila Hawken

MILLBROOK — There is no shortage of talent at The Fountains in Millbrook evidenced by the opening of the Summer Art Show on Thursday, June 11.

Works of several residents are on display in the Gallery for the coming weeks.

Keep ReadingShow less

Francis Lynehan

Francis Lynehan

DOVER PLAINS — Francis “Butch” Lynehan, 75, a twenty-year resident of Dover Plains, New York, formerly of Sharon, passed away unexpectedly on Thursday, May 7, 2026 at Vassar Bros. Medical Center in Poughkeepsie, New York.

Born Aug. 29, 1950, in Sharon, he was the son of the late William W. and Nellie (Kluun) Lynehan.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.