Stabbing fatality on South Amenia Road

AMENIA — Moments before this paper went to press on Tuesday, Jan. 18, New York State Police (NYSP) Public Information Officer A.J. Hicks confirmed that 26-year-old David A. Trotta of Amenia was arrested for Murder in the Second Degree, a class A-I felony, and Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the 4th degree, a class A misdemeanor, on Sunday, Jan. 16, for killing 45-year-old Juan C. Cedillo, just before noon.

Hicks stated that "Troopers were dispatched to South Amenia Road for a report of a stabbing by Dutchess County 911. Once on scene the suspect, David A. Trotta, was immediately taken into custody."

The emergency call was placed to the Dover Plains substation at 11:51 a.m. Although initial news reports stated three people had been stabbed at a South Amenia Road apartment, Wassaic Fire Chief Tim Shea (working in his capacity as a Northern Dutchess Paramedic at the time), clarified the next day there was only the one victim, who was “on the ground with multiple stab wounds to the head” when he arrived on scene.

“No, we got that report too over the initial response,” said Shea. “We were like, ‘Where are the other two?’ But no other victims were there, just the deceased… There was only one stab victim.”

CPR was administered by the Rescue Squad and medics, but the victim was pronounced dead on the scene about 20 minutes after EMS arrived.

“We tried life-saving measures,” said Shea, but to no avail.

The incident took place at 173 South Amenia Road, near the Benton Road intersection.

Along with the NYSP, Capt. John Watterson of the Dutchess County Sheriff's Office (DCSO) confirmed the DCSO "had Deputies on the scene assisting initially, however they cleared pretty quickly once the scene was secure." Watterson noted the NYSP is lead agency in the murder investigation.

Also on scene, added Shea, were the Wassaic Rescue Squad, Amenia Town Medic 1, Dover Town Medic 1, NDP and a number of other emergency crews.

Shea said he didn't know what triggered the stabbing.

“I don’t have any information on what the catalyst was all about,” he said. “When we arrived, the state police had arrived about four minutes before we got there. We had to [wait] until they made it secure. We didn’t see any other residents at all.”

Both Trotta and Cedillo appear to have been residents of the South Amenia Road apartment, according to Hicks.

Trotta was arraigned before the town of Amenia Court and remanded by the Honorable Judge Christopher Klingner to the Dutchess County Jail without bail.

Trotta was scheduled to reappear before the court on Friday, Jan. 21, at 9:30 a.m., but Amenia Court Clerk Dawn Marie Klingner said on Wednesday, Jan. 19, that court date has been adjourned. She said a future date will be set for the defendant to return to court to answer the charges.

Hicks noted the defendant's bail/bond status can always change. He added Trotta's defense attorney will likely make a plea before the judge to modify his bail.   

This article has been updated to note that Trotta's Jan. 21 court date was adjourned to a future date.

Latest News

Pine Plains unveils first phase of major sidewalk repair project

Pine Plains Councilwoman Jeanine Sisco displays a photograph of flashing lights used to alert drivers to pedestrians in crosswalks in Millerton during a public forum at Pine Plains Town Hall on Tuesday, March 3. Sisco outlined plans to repair sidewalks and install two new crosswalks in downtown Pine Plains as a first phase in sidewalk repairs across the town.

Photo by Nathan Miller

PINE PLAINS — Town Board members unveiled plans for sidewalk renovations in downtown Pine Plains as they prepare to apply for a federal grant to fund the first phase of the project.

Councilwoman Jeanine Sisco described the first phase of the sidewalk project at a public forum at Pine Plains Town Hall on Tuesday, March 3.

Keep ReadingShow less
Living art takes center stage in the Berkshires

Contemporary chamber musicians, HUB, performing at The Clark.

D.H. Callahan

Northwestern Massachusetts may sometimes feel remote, but last weekend it felt like the center of the contemporary art world.

Within 15 miles of each other, MASS MoCA in North Adams and the Clark Art Institute in Williamstown showcased not only their renowned historic collections, but an impressive range of living artists pushing boundaries in technology, identity and sound.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Persistently amplifying women’s voices

Francesca Donner, founder and editor of The Persistent. Subscribe at thepersistent.com.

Aly Morrissey

Francesca Donner pours a cup of tea in the cozy library of Troutbeck’s Manor House in Amenia, likely a habit she picked up during her formative years in the United Kingdom. Flanked by old books and a roaring fire, Donner feels at home in the quiet room, where she spends much of her time working as founder, editor and CEO of The Persistent, a journalism platform created to amplify women’s voices.

Although her parents are American and she spent her earliest years in New York City and Litchfield County — even attending Washington Montessori School as a preschooler — Donner moved to England at around five years old and completed most of her education there. Her accent still bears the imprint of what she describes as a traditional English schooling.

Keep ReadingShow less
Jarrett Porter on the enduring power of Schubert’s ‘Winterreise’
Baritone Jarrett Porter to perform Schubert’s “Winterreise”
Tim Gersten

On March 7, Berkshire Opera Festival will bring “Winterreise” to Studio E at Tanglewood’s Linde Center for Music and Learning, with baritone Jarrett Porter and BOF Artistic Director and pianist Brian Garman performing Franz Schubert’s haunting 24-song setting of poems by Wilhelm Müller.

A rejected lover. A frozen landscape. A mind unraveling in real time. Nearly 200 years after its premiere, “Winterreise” remains unnervingly current in its psychological portrait of isolation, heartbreak and existential drift.

Keep ReadingShow less
A grand finale for Crescendo’s 22nd season

Christine Gevert, artistic director, brings together international and local musicians for a season of rare works.

Stephen Potter

Crescendo, the Lakeville-based nonprofit specializing in early and rarely performed classical music, will close its 22nd season with a slate of spring concerts featuring international performers, local musicians and works by pioneering composers from the Baroque era to the 20th century.

Christine Gevert, the organization’s artistic director, has gathered international vocal and instrumental talent, blending it with local voices to provide Berkshire audiences with rare musical treats.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.