Antibody tests now at Sharon Hospital

SHARON — As society slowly emerges from the COVID-19 quarantine, the question on the minds of many people has shifted from “Do I have the virus?” to “Did I have the virus?” — and therefore, do I have immunity from reinfection?

Even as antibody tests become available, uncertainty surrounds the issue, including how much protection is offered even if someone tests positive for COVID-19 antibodies.

“Right now, no one knows what the presence of antibodies really means,” said Dr. Mark Hirko, president of Sharon Hospital, where FDA-approved serological, or antibody testing, is now offered. 

“Are they safe from reinfection? Safe from not being contagious?” 

Currently, he said, there are no clear answers.  Even if antibodies were found to provide immunity, Hirko said, it is not known how long that protection would last.

Antibodies are proteins made in response to infections, such as COVID-19. They can be found in the blood of people who are tested after infection, showing that they have had an immune response to the coronavirus. 

But some health professionals, and the Centers for Disease Control and Protection (CDC), caution that rushing out to get tested for antibodies is not advisable, as the test has limitations. 

“This test is not currently designed for individual use … to test people who want to know if they have been previously infected with SARS-CoV-2,” according to the CDC. Rather, the serologic test has been “designed and validated for broad-based surveillance and research purposes, to provide information needed to guide the response to the pandemic, and protect the public’s health.”

Not all tests are alike

Sharon Hospital, said Hirko, “is the only hospital in the Nuvance Health system offering the antibody test,” which aids physicians in determining who may be eligible to donate a part of their blood, called convalescent plasma, which may serve as a possible treatment for those who are most seriously ill from the virus. 

Although a number of commercially manufactured antibody tests that check for the coronavirus are available through health-care providers and commercial laboratories, Hirko said Sharon Hospital  is “using the test that received FDA approval,” as are other hospitals.

The test requires a blood draw, as opposed to other methods that may use a sample of blood taken from a finger prick or a swab test. There are hundreds of antibody tests out there that you can order online, Hirko cautioned, “but it is unknown as to the FDA approval status of the myriad of testing equipment available on the internet.” 

As Connecticut navigates its initial phase of reopening businesses, and in response to individuals and employers who see antibody testing as part of reentry into society, several statewide urgent care clinics have reported they are also offering antibody testing. 

False sense of security

Hirko said that unlike the nasopharyngeal tests used to diagnose COVID-19, antibody tests at Sharon Hospital is not free of charge and might not be covered by insurance. A prescription is required; the patient must not have symptoms of the virus or if they suspect they have been exposed to the virus, they must wait 10 days before testing. 

The Sharon Hospital president cautioned that while the antibody tests seem to be more reliable than the viral diagnostic tests, the hospital does not want to give people a false sense of security should they test positive for antibodies. 

“Nasal swabs have been very accurate. The Abbott rapid studies have a 12 percent to 48 percent false negative rate, which is not good, and this study [of the antibodies] is a lot more accurate — in the 90s and even higher,” said Hirko.

Sailors reinfected?

Even so, Hirko offered this caveat, which he said is worrisome: The U.S. Navy has reported that five sailors from the virus-stricken USS Theodore Roosevelt who had recovered from COVID-19 and received two negative test results, recently tested positive for a second coronavirus infection. 

That brings the total of reported reinfected crew members to 13, according to the Navy. It remains unclear whether the tests were faulty, or if the sailors were reinfected aboard the ship, docked in Guam.

In a statement, the Food and Drug Administration said that, “At this time, it is unknown for how long antibodies persist following infection and if the presence of antibodies confers protective immunity.” 

The hope is that ultimately the test will aid researchers in better understanding how widespread the coronavirus is.

It is unlikely, said Hirko, that scientific research on  antibodies will become available for at least one year to 18 months. 

“Right now, we are four months in with a brand new virus. It’s hard to fathom, we have so many things to figure out. We don’t know what the threshold is that would confer immunity. That is the great unknown.”

Related Articles Around the Web

Latest News

Crescendo’s upcoming tribute to Wanda Landowska

Kenneth Weiss (above) will play a solo recital performance in honor of Wanda Landowska, a harpischord virtuoso, who lived in Lakeville for many years.

Provided

On Sept. 14, Crescendo, the award-winning music program based in Lakeville, will present a harpsichord solo recital by Kenneth Weiss in honor of world-renowned harpsichordist Wanda Landowska. Landowska lived in Lakeville from 1941 to 1959. Weiss is a professor at the Paris Conservatoire and has taught at Julliard. Born in New York, he now resides in Europe.

Weiss will play selections from “A Treasury of Harpsichord Music.” It includes works by Baroque composers such as Bach, Mozart, and Handel. It was recorded by Landowska at her Lakeville home, at 63 Millerton Road, which overlooks Lakeville Lake. Weiss said, “I am honored and excited to play in Lakeville, where Wanda Landowska lived.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Silent cinema, live magic

The live audience at Music Mountain takes in a silent film Sept. 7.

Natalia Zukerman

On Saturday, Sept. 7, Gordon Hall at Music Mountain was transformed into a time machine, transporting the audience for a 1920’s spectacular of silent films and live music. Featuring internationally acclaimed silent film musicians Donald Sosin and Joanna Seaton, the evening began with a singalong of songs by Gershwin, Irving Berlin and more. Lyrics for favorites like “Ain’t We Got Fun,” “Yes Sir That’s My Baby,” and “Ain’t Misbehavin’” were projected on the screen and Sosin and Seaton lead the crowd with an easeful joy. The couple then retreated to the side of the stage where they provided the live and improvised score for Buster Keaton’s 1922 short, “Cops,” and his 1924 comedy, “Sherlock Jr.”

Joanna Seaton and Donald Sosin, a husband-and-wife duo, have crafted a singular career, captivating audiences at some of the world’s most prestigious film festivals—New York, TriBeCa, San Francisco, Seattle, Denver, Telluride, and Yorkshire among them. Their performances have graced venerable institutions like MoMA, Film at Lincoln Center, the AFI Silver Theatre, and Moscow’s celebrated Lumière Gallery. Their melodic journey has taken them to far-flung locales such as the Thailand Silent Film Festival and the Jecheon International Music and Film Festival in South Korea. Notably, Seaton and Sosin have become a fixture at Italy’s renowned silent film festivals in Bologna and Pordenone, where they perform annually.

Keep ReadingShow less
Desperately seeking Susan Seidelman

The cover art for Seidelman's memoir "Desperately Seeking Something."

Photo Provided

On Thursday, Sept. 19 at 6 p.m., Haystack Book Talks will present a special evening with director Susan Seidelman, author of “Desperately Seeking Something: A Memoir About Movies, Mothers, and Material Girls.” Part of the Haystack Book Festival run by Michael Selleck, the event will take place at the Norfolk Library, featuring a conversation with Mark Erder after a screening of the 1984 classic, “Desperately Seeking Susan.”

Susan Seidelman’s fearless debut film, “Smithereens,” premiered in 1982 and was the first American indie film to ever compete at Cannes. Then came “Desperately Seeking Susan,” a smash hit that not only solidified her place in Hollywood but helped launch Madonna’s career. Her films, blending classic Hollywood storytelling with New York’s downtown energy, feature unconventional women navigating unique lives. Seidelman continued to shape pop culture into the ’90s, directing the pilot for “Sex and the City.” Four decades later, Seidelman’s stories are still as sharp, funny, and insightful as ever.

Keep ReadingShow less