Millerton Plaza sold for $1.75 million

Millerton Plaza sold for $1.75 million

The house at 22 State Line Road on 3.22 acres just outside the Village of Millerton in the Town of North East sits right next to the road. Built in 1910, it was owned by an absentee owner who lived in Brazil and sold after a number of years for $137,101 to RG Duell LLC.

Photo by Christine bates

MILLERTON — Recorded transfers of property are informative because they include all real estate ownership changes — not just ones handled by real estate brokers. Off-market sales tend to be between friends or family, properties “sold by owner,” distressed situations, and often commercial properties such as the sale of the Millerton Plaza, the Town of North East’s supermarket, for $1.75 million. The sale of the “Ice House” at 12 State Line Road by the owner — whose address is in Rio de Janeiro — for only $160,000 is an example of a distressed sale that took years and was never publicly listed. In December of the eight recorded transfers only three were listed on any MLS. The four residential properties transferred privately all sold at prices well below the three publicly listed houses.

In Mid-January the Town of North East had 12 homes listed for sale ranging from $399,000 to $5.9 million, and 16 parcels of land also with a huge range of $3.4 million to five building lots for less than $79,000.

49 Simmons St. — 3 bedroom/2 bath renovated village house on .38 acres sold for $505,000.

31 Traver Place — 3 bedroom/2 bath house sold for $437,500.

20 Haight Road — 3 bedroom/1.5 bath house sold off-market for $160,000.

144 Skunks Misery Road — additional .98 acres of land in a lot line alteration sold off-market for $50,000.

6118 Route 22 — 4 bedroom/1 bath house sold off-market for $220,000.

12 State Line Road — long abandoned 3 bedroom/2 bath house on 3.81 acres known as the Ice House sold off-market for $137,101.

47 Skunks Misery Road — 2 bedroom/3 bath house on 23.67 acres sold for $725,000.

122 Route 44 — Millerton Plaza — 4 parcels on 4.9 acres formerly the Millerton Grand Union, Trotta Liquor, Trotta Law office, and Riley’s Furniture sold privately by Joseph Trotta to North East Plaza LLC for $1.75 million.

*Town of North East and Village of Millerton real estate sales recorded between Dec. 1, 2024, and Dec. 31, 2024, sourced from Dutchess County Real Property Tax Service Agency. Information on active listings taken from First Key MLS which may understate available properties. Only transfers with consideration are included. Compiled by Christine Bates, Real Estate Advisor with William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty, Licensed in Connecticut and New York.

Latest News

Cold temperatures cause two water main breaks in Amenia

A water main under Indian Lake Road in Amenia sprays water after construction workers with C. Gallagher Contracting, of Brewster, New York, attempted to cut the pipe to replace a damaged section on Tuesday, Jan. 27. Crew members said high pressure in a pipe encumbers cutting, fills the hole with too much water, and could cause workers to be too wet for the extremely low temperatures.

Photo by Nathan Miller

AMENIA — Amenia's water system struggled under the stress of frigid temperatures on Tuesday, Jan. 27, as two leaks sprung from water mains in different parts of town.

An emergency break under Indian Lake Road required a section of pipe be removed and completely replaced. C. Gallagher Contracting of Brewster, New York, provided excavation and pipe repair services for both breaks.

Keep ReadingShow less
Northeast Dutchess County digs out, braces for more snow

Stanford locals utilize the snow covered hill below Stanford Town Hall on Route 82 on Friday, Jan. 23, before the weekend's snow storm deposited up to 18 inches across northeast Dutchess County.

Photo by Nathan Miller

Heavy snow blanketed Dutchess County on Sunday, Jan. 25, triggering a county-wide travel ban and a state of emergency.

Parts of the northeast corner of the county saw as many as 18 inches of snow. Temperatures are projected to remain below freezing well into next week.

Keep ReadingShow less
Dutchess County lifts travel ban after up to 18 inches of snow

Route 44/82 west of Millbrook, near Cornell Cooperative Extension, was clear as of 2 p.m. Monday, Jan. 26, following the snowstorm.

By Nathan Miller

Dutchess County officials lifted the county-wide travel at noon Monday, Jan. 26.

The announcement came Monday morning at 9:30 after heavy snowfall Sunday blanketed the county with up to 18 inches in some places, according to totals reported on the National Weather Service's website.

Keep ReadingShow less
Snow storm triggers county-wide travel ban

Snow covered Route 44/22 near the Maplebrook School campus in Amenia at 10:30 a.m. Sunday, Jan. 25.

Photo by Nathan Miller

Dutchess County officials issued a travel ban on all public roads from 5 a.m. Sunday, Jan. 25, to 5 p.m. Monday, Jan. 26.

The National Weather Service issued a Winter Storm Warning for much of upstate New York on Friday. Forecasts call for between 10 and 20 inches of snow across northeast Dutchess County.

Keep ReadingShow less