Towns take differing approaches to religious displays on public property

Towns take differing approaches to religious displays on public property

The yard in front of the Thorne Building on Franklin Avenue in Millbrook hosts a large menorah. The Millbrook Chanukah Committee has scheduled a lighting ceremony for Sunday, Dec. 21, at 4 p.m. on the Thorne Building lawn.

Photo by Aly Morrissey

As municipalities across the region grapple with how to balance faith, inclusion and the use of public space during the holiday season, communities are arriving at different conclusions about interfaith observances and religious symbols on municipal property.

Several towns continue to host public menorah lightings as community events. In Stanford, Millbrook and Amenia, the celebrations are framed as inclusive gatherings rather than formal religious endorsements.

In Stanford, residents are invited to a public menorah lighting on Wednesday, Dec. 17, at 5:30 p.m. at Town Hall. The event, hosted by Chabad of Dutchess County, will include donuts and hot latkes.

Millbrook will hold its menorah lighting Sunday, Dec. 21, at 4 p.m. at the Thorne Building on Franklin Avenue. The celebration will continue afterward at Babette’s Kitchen on Franklin Avenue with hot latkes, warm apple cider, coffee, baked goods and festive singing.

In Amenia, resident Ken Topolsky installed a menorah at Town Hall on Tuesday, Dec. 16, and the town will host a lighting ceremony on Sunday, Dec. 21.

In contrast, officials in the Village of Millerton have expressed reluctance to allow a menorah in Veterans Park, citing concerns about introducing new faith-based displays on public property. Village leaders say the policy reflects a long-standing effort to keep seasonal decorations secular.

The response comes as the village continues long-standing seasonal traditions centered on secular displays. Each year, white holiday lights are strung throughout the village by the volunteer group Townscape, and the annual Festival of Lights parade features Santa Claus and other Christmas-themed imagery.

In a written statement to The News, Millerton Mayor Jenn Najdek said the village’s policy is rooted in maintaining neutrality toward religion.

“By avoiding standalone faith-based symbols like nativity scenes or menorahs, the village maintains government neutrality toward religion, preventing any perception of endorsing one faith over others or religion over non-religion,” Najdek wrote.

Debate over religious displays has become more pointed in the Village of Rhinebeck, where rumors have circulated that this may be the final year a large menorah will be permitted in Doughboy Park.

Those concerns came to light after Rabbi Hanoch Hecht of the Rhinebeck Jewish Community Center sent an email to residents urging them to contact village officials and express support for keeping the menorah in the park. Some residents believe a change in policy — potentially taking effect in 2026 — could result in the removal of all religious symbols from municipal property, including a Christmas tree.

Hecht emphasized the broader symbolism of Hanukkah amid rising concerns about global antisemitism.

“We live in a very dark world, especially after incidents like what recently took place in Sydney,” Hecht said, referring to the fatal terror attack at a Hanukkah celebration in Australia on Sunday, Dec. 14, that left 15 people dead.

He said that while the attacks feel geographically distant, it has contributed to a broader sense of unease among Jewish communities worldwide.

Rhinebeck Mayor Gary Bassett said reports of a definitive decision are premature and stressed that no final determination has been made.

“Rabbi Hecht and I are very much engaged, working in collaboration for events both this year and for the future,” Bassett said. “That’s how this conversation started, by getting together and talking.”

Bassett declined to comment on reports from web-based news source The Daily Catch that the New York Conference of Mayors (NYCOM) advised his office to remove faith-based symbols from municipal property. The News independently confirmed those guidelines.

In a written statement, NYCOM’s executive director Barbara Van Epps wrote, “NYCOM generally advises against local governments erecting religious displays on municipal property. Although there are limited circumstances in which such displays may be permissible without violating the First Amendment, it can be difficult to navigate both legally and politically.” Van Epps added that the best course of action is to make the display entirely secular.

Latest News

New climbing gym planned for Great Barrington

Photo by Alec Linden

A climber explores Great Barrington’s renowned bouldering areas, reflecting the growing local interest in the sport ahead of the planned opening of Berkshire Boulders.

Alec Linden

Berkshire Boulders, a rock climbing gym, is set to open in the Berkshires later this year, aiming to do more than fill a gap in indoor recreation — it could help bring climbing further into the region’s mainstream.

Its co-founders already have their sights set beyond the roughly 2,000 square feet of climbable wall planned for a site off Route 7, just north of downtown Great Barrington.

Keep ReadingShow less
Wind, tarps and trail wisdom: a day learning how to camp smarter

Mat Jobin teaches the group how to use a permanent platform to rig a tent. The privy and lean-to of the Appalachian Mountain Club’s Limestone Spring Shelter are visible in the background.

Alec Linden

A happy day on the trail all starts with a good night’s sleep the night before. That’s local trekking guide Mat Jobin’s mantra, and he affirms that a good night’s sleep is possible even if it has to be on the trail itself – with the right preparation, that is.

Jobin, of Simsbury, Connecticut, is a 16-year professional guide and the founder and owner of Reach Your Summit, an outdoor experiences company that promotes self-confidence and leadership skills through a variety of excursions and educational workshops in the forests of New England. On Saturday, April 11, Jobin hosted the inaugural Campsite Selection & Skills workshop just off the Falls Village section of the Appalachian Trail.

Keep ReadingShow less
Grandmother Moon: Wunneanatsu Lamb-Cason book talk in Torrington

The story comes full circle when educator, traditional storyteller and author Wunneanatsu Lamb-Cason (Schaghticoke/Ho-Chunk) comes to Litchfield County to read from her new book, Grandmother Moon, inspired by her grandmother, Indigenous educator Trudie Lamb Richmond, who lived on Schaghticoke land along the Housatonic River in Kent.

On Saturday, April 18, from 2-4 p.m., the Torrington Historical Society at 192 Main St. will host the book talk and sharing of traditional stories.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Photographer David Ricci’s New Book at Five Points Art Center

“Everything Everywhere All At Once,” a photo from David Ricci’s book Hunter Gatherer.

Photo by David Ricci - Hunter/Gatherer

David Ricci will bring his exploration of American materialism to the Five Points Arts Center in Torrington on Saturday, April 18, at 2 p.m., where he will discuss his new book, Hunter Gatherer.

Ricci is fascinated by America’s obsession with objects. In Hunter Gatherer, he examines a distinct strain of materialism—one rooted not in the new, but in the items that endure.

Keep ReadingShow less

NEAR and FAR

NEAR and FAR

“WHATSTOCOMEHASALREADYBEEN” by Richard Marr 40x30 (2021)

Photo Provided

Tyte Gallery, located on the 2nd floor at 3280 Franklin Ave. in Millbrook, presents NEAR and FAR, a solo exhibition of new work by Richard Marr, opening with a reception April 18 from 6 to 9 p.m. Marr’s immersive landscape paintings explore the movement and force of water—from ocean waves to the Hudson River—while reflecting on nature’s interconnected rhythms and humanity’s place within them. On view through June 7.

Students get a taste of the real world during Career Day

Ella Emberlin, an eighth grader at Salisbury Central School, meets alum Colby Hickey, owner of Colby’s Tree Service, on Career Day.

Madi Long

SHARON – Sharon Center School students got a firsthand look at potential career paths on Friday, April 10, during their annual Career Day, where guest speakers from a range of fields spoke with students in fourth through eighth grade.

The annual event is organized by school counselor Liz Foster, who aims to showcase the positions held by local community members. Presenters included a meteorologist, scuba diving instructor, mechanic and attorney.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.