County challenges even-year voting
North East Town Hall
Photo by John Coston

County challenges even-year voting

POUGHKEEPSIE — The Dutchess County Legislature passed a resolution authorizing the use of $100,000 of taxpayer funds to challenge a state Senate bill designed to increase voter turnout and save money in local elections by moving some local elections to even-numbered years.

On Tuesday, April 9, the county legislature voted for the resolution 14-7, along party lines, with the Republican majority voting for the appropriation. Proponents of the appropriation claim that the state’s action is a violation of home rule.

The law in question

Governor Kathy Hochul signed senate bill S3505B, which moves certain local elections to even numbered years, into law last December. It was the latest version of a bill that has been in the works since January 2023; earlier versions have been brought in nearly every session since at least 2013.

“Aligning local elections with general elections has been proven to be one of the single most effective ways to not only reduce the turnout gaps by race and age, but also to improve governance outcomes so that local governments are better reflective of the will of their constituents,” said Harvard Law School’s Election Law Clinic in a statement applauding the measure.

At the signing, Hochul noted that the statewide turnout in the 2020 election was 64% of registered voters, compared to 25% for local elections in 2021.

2020 was a presidential election, so a comparison to the state, local and gubernatorial elections of 2022, which had a 43% turnout, is also worth noting — as is the 18% percent statewide voter turnout in 2023 local elections.

“When elections are held in odd-numbered years, away from the traditional election cycle that voters are most familiar with, the cost of participating in the democratic process is increased, particularly for voters who may have a difficult time arranging for time off of work and traveling to their polling site,” explained the Governor’s office in a statement. “By consolidating more elections in even-numbered years when most voters are already planning to participate in an election, this change will increase voter participation in important local races.”

In Dutchess County, voter turnout was 78% in 2020, but fell to 34% for elections held in 2021 and 2023. In addition to dramatically increasing voter turnout for municipal and local elections, it would also save local taxpayers money, proponents have noted.

At the signing, Gov. Hochul underscored the point, saying, “Every eligible New Yorker deserves the right to participate in the democratic process without unnecessary barriers. By signing this legislation, we are taking a significant step towards expanding access to the ballot box and promoting a more inclusive democracy.”

The law consolidates all elections into even years, though legislators are working on an amendment to the state constitution that would make that possible. Until then, all local elections in New York City and all elections for city and village positions, school board seats, judges, county sheriffs, clerks and district attorneys will continue to take place on odd-numbered years.

Dutchess County’s challenge

By moving certain elections to even-numbered years, the new law amended the town law, the village law, the county law, and the municipal home rule law of several constituencies, including the Dutchess County charter, which specifically states that local elections must take place during odd-numbered years.

“The charter, which was enacted by the residents of the county, specifically states that elections for county offices are to be held in odd-numbered years,” said Majority Leader Deirdre Houston (R-District 25), who represents Amenia, Millbrook, Washington and Pleasant Valley. “New York State decided to unilaterally change the mode of our elections without so much as consulting the voters of Dutchess County.”

“I made it clear the day I became chairman that we would fight this unconstitutional power grab with any available measure,” said Dutchess County Legislature Chairman Will Truitt (R-Hyde Park). “Every member of the legislature swore an oath at our Organizational Meeting in January to uphold the county charter. We simply cannot sit idly by as the state attempts to circumvent the very charter that we all swore to uphold.”

Other proponents of the lawsuit have said that the new law would actually cost more money, requiring the hiring of more election staff on even-numbered years, rather than saving money longterm by decreasing staffing and other needs on odd-numbered years. They have also voiced concerns that if local elections are held in even-numbered years, national issues and national partisanship will overshadow local concerns. In general, however, statements explaining the suit have mostly adhered to concerns about “home rule.”

Describing the changes as “monumental,” Houston said, “in my view, [the new law] represents a blatant disregard for the people of Dutchess County and their desire for local control.”

Proponents of the law have accused the county’s Republican legislators of being politically motivated, and say that they are acting to protect the party’s edge in local elections, which could be at risk if voter turnout increased.

“This is a waste of money. The County budget is extremely tight due to years of budget mismanagement, and there are more important needs in our community that must be addressed first,” said Chris Drago (D - District 19), who represents North East, Stanford, Pine Plains, Milan and Red Hook.

“We need to be investing in vital needs for our community: EMS, transportation, mental health and keeping Cornell Cooperative Extension’s door open so they can continue to support agriculture, and environmental and Youth Services for our community.”

He continued: “This is the first major issue that this legislative body has taken up since we took office, and it’s about limiting voter turnout.” He added, “It’s embarrassing.”

Onondaga and Nassau Counties have also filed challenges, listing similar concerns; the Oneida County legislature has also authorized a potential lawsuit. All three legislatures have a Republican majority.

Dutchess County’s budget appropriation of $100,000 is expected to be enacted by County Executive Sue Serino.

If the law survives challenges by Dutchess and other counties, which it is expected to do, officials elected after Jan. 1, 2025 will serve shortened terms.

Dutchess County legislators, who typically serve two-year terms and were last elected in November, will run for re-election in 2025, but serve terms concluding in 2026. The next election for Dutchess County executive, normally a four-year position, would take place in 2027, then again in 2030.

Latest News

Love is in the atmosphere

Author Anne Lamott

Sam Lamott

On Tuesday, April 9, The Bardavon 1869 Opera House in Poughkeepsie was the setting for a talk between Elizabeth Lesser and Anne Lamott, with the focus on Lamott’s newest book, “Somehow: Thoughts on Love.”

A best-selling novelist, Lamott shared her thoughts about the book, about life’s learning experiences, as well as laughs with the audience. Lesser, an author and co-founder of the Omega Institute in Rhinebeck, interviewed Lamott in a conversation-like setting that allowed watchers to feel as if they were chatting with her over a coffee table.

Keep ReadingShow less
Reading between the lines in historic samplers

Alexandra Peter's collection of historic samplers includes items from the family of "The House of the Seven Gables" author Nathaniel Hawthorne.

Cynthia Hochswender

The home in Sharon that Alexandra Peters and her husband, Fred, have owned for the past 20 years feels like a mini museum. As you walk through the downstairs rooms, you’ll see dozens of examples from her needlework sampler collection. Some are simple and crude, others are sophisticated and complex. Some are framed, some lie loose on the dining table.

Many of them have museum cards, explaining where those samplers came from and why they are important.

Keep ReadingShow less