Amenia home price gap widens

Amenia home price gap widens

With a price of $1.83 million, 460 Sinpatch Road, formerly a dairy farm and now a horse operation, was the most expensive property sold in Amenia in the last 60 days. The property includes a main residence with 5 bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms, plus a carriage house and a cottage, multiple agricultural buildings and 175 acres of land.

Photo by Christine Bates

AMENIA — Even without the inclusion of high-priced homes at Silo Ridge, the same wide price gap persists in Amenia home sales.

In the last 60 days, seven properties have been closed. Five of those homes were on small lots, selling for $310,000 and below.

One 153-acre land parcel sold for $800,000, and one historic farm complex for $1.83 million. Starting this week, recent real estate activity will only show sales of publicly listed properties and will exclude private transfers which have previously been included.

In the case of Amenia, most sales within the Silo Ridge Club are private and will only become available once Dutchess County resumes reporting on all property transfers, private and public, in July.

This wide price gap is even more apparent in homes on the market with six residential properties listed for over $2 million, while 11 homes were available under $500,000 with nothing in between.

13 Glen Hill — 3 bedroom/ 1 bath home on .51 acres sold on March 19 for $245,000.

3367 Route 22 — 2 bedroom/1 bath home on .45 acres sold on March 24 for $245,000.

212 Old Route 22 — 5 bedroom/3 bath triplex in Wassaic on .22 acres sold on March 25 for $170,000.

13 Lango Road — 3 bedroom/1 bath home on .5 acres sold on March 25 for $310,000.

426 Old Route 22 — 152.9 acres of land sold on April 4 for $800,000.

460 Sinpatch Road — farm complex on 174.96 acres sold on April 9 for $1.83 million.

* Town of Amenia closed real estate sales for the 60 days ending April 24 are sourced from One Key MLS. Information on active listings taken from First Key MLS. Private transfers are not included. Compiled by Christine Bates, Real Estate Advisor with William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty, Licensed in Connecticut and New York.

Latest News

Governor Hochul implements temporary statewide burn ban

The LED sign in front of Amenia's Town Hall on Route 22 warns passing motorists of the current temporary burn ban, in effect from Oct. 2 to Oct. 15.

Photo by Nathan Miller

A statewide burn ban is in effect as of Thursday, Oct. 2, the New York State Governor's office announced in a press release.

The temporary ban is in effect until at least Oct. 15, and the statement released by the governor's office said the restrictions will be re-evaluated prior to the Oct. 15 deadline.

Keep ReadingShow less
Barbara Meyers DelPrete

LAKEVILLE, Conn. — Barbara Meyers DelPrete, 84, passed away Tuesday, September 30, 2025.

A Funeral Mass will be celebrated Saturday, October 4, 2025, at 11:00a.m. at St. Mary’s Church, 76 Sharon Rd., Lakeville.

Keep ReadingShow less
Stanford’s Haunted Fortress gearing up for opening day

Volunteers were hard at work putting the finishing touches on the crucial creepy decorations for the Haunted Fortress of Stanford on Sunday, Sept. 28.

Nathan Miller

STANFORD — Greg Arent led a devoted team of volunteers on Sunday, Sept. 28, in a final push to prepare Stanford’s Haunted Fortress for opening day.

Final touches included cleaning the bottomless pit, scrubbing the pirate ship, raking the graveyard and dressing the dolls. By 2 p.m., about 20 volunteers had assembled to creepify the beloved local landmark.

Keep ReadingShow less
Millerton Public Works Superintendent resigns, Police Chief takes the job

From left, Jim Milton, Spencer Parks and William J. Clark stand with Joseph Olenik on their first day working under him as the head of Public Works on Monday, Sept. 29.

Aly Morrissey

MILLERTON — The Village announced a leadership change at the Highway Department on Friday following the resignation of Superintendent Peter Dellaghelfa. Police Chief Joseph Olenik will step into the role, effective immediately, officials said.

Olenik will continue to serve as Police Chief.

Keep ReadingShow less