Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

Arraigned and released: Former hostage taker arrested on gun charges

PINE PLAINS — The Pine Plains community was distressed to learn about the arrest of  Christopher Craft on Wednesday, April 20, following a traffic stop in Hyde Park for a number of traffic violations.

Craft is the former Stanfordville resident who served seven years in state prison for holding former Stissing Mountain Middle School Principal Bob Hess hostage with a loaded shotgun in 2009.

Last week’s arrest occurred after New York State Police (NYSP) troopers pulled over Craft’s 1994 Ford van over on Route 9 along the western edge of the county.

Troopers from the Rhinebeck Troop K barracks discovered Craft, 55, and his son, Jeremy Craft, 32, both of whom now live in Rhinebeck, with a loaded Mossberg 500A 12-gauge shotgun. That’s “despite both being convicted of crimes barring them from possessing a firearm,” according to the NYSP.

The vehicle, in addition to containing the loaded firearm, was also carrying an unrestrained child in the front seat, noted the NYSP. 

“During the arrest, Christopher Craft refused to comply with lawful orders,” according to the police report.

The father and son were charged with Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the 4th degree; Endangering the Welfare of a Child, both class A misdemeanors; and Possession of a Loaded Firearm in a Motor Vehicle, an unclassified misdemeanor. 

Christopher Craft was additionally arrested for Obstruction of Governmental Administration, a class A misdemeanor.

The Crafts were arraigned before the town of Hyde Park Court and released on their own recognizance to reappear in court on Monday, May 9.

Chair of the Dutchess County Legislature Gregg Pulver (R-19) remembers when Craft took Hess hostage in 2009 “as if it was yesterday,” he said. He was the Pine Plains town supervisor at the time.

“That situation was the toughest point of my career in public service,” posted Pulver on his Facebook page on Friday, April 22, calling for changes to the state’s controversial bail reform laws. “Now, to see this man was arrested again for weapons charges and subsequently released [with tickets] is beyond explanation.”

New York State Police Public Information Officer A.J. Hicks of Troop K in Salt Point addressed Pulver’s concern.

“They were arraigned and released on their own recognizance,” said Hicks. “It’s not like they were given appearance tickets. The Crafts were arraigned before the judge and he made them understand the charges, I don’t know if that counts in legal term as getting tickets.”

On Tuesday, April 26, Pulver said the Crafts being released at all speaks to what’s wrong with New York laws.

“He’s a felon, so he can’t have a weapon, and he had a loaded weapon in his vehicle…  The shocking thing is not so much he’s in trouble with the law, the shocking thing is someone with this record is still released without bail,” said Pulver. “This is a guy who held up the school and caused emotional harm to hundreds of people: kids, parents, teachers… Judges need more tools, that’s all I’m saying… Certainly people are held waiting on bail who shouldn’t have been, but in this case bail was appropriate and should have been a tool for the judge to use.”

Pulver added someone like Craft, with a long criminal history that includes repeated violations of various gun laws, needs to get treatment, as well as be behind bars.

“He obviously has some psychological issues here, but they just released him. There has to be more done,” said Pulver. “The sad thing is these things perpetuate. Here’s the case of someone not getting the help they need mentally, and bringing the next generation down with them. We have to end that cycle one way or another.”

Hostage history

Back in 2009, Christopher Craft had threatened to kill Principal Hess in order to force school officials and police to talk with the media about the “wrongful treatment of United States Military personnel,” according to court documents at the time.

When the incident occurred, Jeremy told the media his father was upset because of how his brother, Christopher, was treated in the military. Christopher Craft Jr. was a motor transportation operator who was injured while serving in the Army between December 2006 through June 2009; he reportedly had difficulty getting social services upon his return.

Craft had two sons attending the Pine Plains Central School District in 2009, but school officials then said neither was enrolled when he restrained Hess in an inner office.

Craft had a criminal history dating back 10 years before the 2009 stand-off. Those crimes included burglary, petty larceny, resisting arrest, possession of stolen property, disobeying a court order and criminal mischief.

During the hostage situation, the school went into lockdown while SWAT teams and hundreds of police officers responded to the scene. Two hours later, Craft surrendered to authorities.

The senior assistant district attorney (ADA), Edward Whitesell, who tried the case in Dutchess County Court asked Judge Gerald Hayes to sentence Craft to the maximum prison term of 15 years. Whitesell argued Craft had a pattern of reacting adversely when upset, with escalating anger. The ADA was also reported to have argued that Craft might have had just three prior misdemeanor convictions at the time, but had been arrested 26 times by then.

Whitesell was also quoted in a 2010 Daily Freeman calling Craft a “narcissist bully” during his sentencing.

Many residents living in and around Pine Plains took to Facebook last week following Craft’s arrest expressing concern, both of his recent behavior and of gun and bail reform laws in New York State.

Some referred to the former gunman as a “loose cannon,” while others said
“We need gun reform. Period.”

Others praised Pulver for speaking out about his not agreeing with Craft’s release due to his long criminal history and what he put the town of Pine Plains and its school district through back in 2009.

 

Latest News

Boondocks Film Society brings exclusive screening to drive-in

Jorma Taccone, left, takes part in a Q&A before a screening of "Hot Rod" at Four Brothers Drive-In in Amenia on Aug. 31, 2023.

AMENIA — Four Brothers Drive-In will host a screening of the new dark comedy Over Your Dead Body on Thursday, Aug. 6, with director Jorma Taccone on hand for a pre-screening Q&A as part of a partnership with the Boondocks Film Society.

The film stars Samara Weaving and Jason Segel as a married couple. Each is secretly plotting to kill the other. Taccone, a North Canaan resident and founding member of the comedy troupe The Lonely Island, will discuss the film before the screening.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Baseball, wine and jazz at Millbrook Winery

Bernie Williams and his Band of Friends at Millbrook Winery in 2025.

Provided

Throughout the history of Major League Baseball, precious few greats have been considered five-tool players. New York Yankee Bernie Williams was one of them.

To be considered a five tool player, one must show exceptional proficiency in five categories: hitting for average, hitting for power, running bases, fielding and arm strength. But there’s another tool Williams possesses that didn’t make it to the back of his baseball card: his mastery of jazz guitar.

Keep ReadingShow less
Lucky Orphans offers sanctuary for horses and healing for people
If horses could speak, Hearn believes they would offer just one piece of advice: “They’d tell us to slow down.”

From feeding retired racehorses before sunrise to guiding veterans, grieving parents and troubled teenagers through equine-assisted therapy sessions, Deanna Hearn rarely has a quiet day. As founder of Lucky Orphans Horse Rescue in Dover Plains, she oversees the care of more than 40 sanctuary horses while leading a nonprofit whose mission extends far beyond animal rescue.

What began as a childhood love of horses has evolved into a place where healing runs in both directions — for horses and for people. By the time you leave Lucky Orphans, it becomes clear that this place isn’t really about horses. The horses are simply how it begins. For Hearn, every rescued horse represents something much larger: hope, resilience, healing and second chances. The organization’s mission, she says, is simple: “People helping horses heal people.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Weekend in Norfolk returns for four days of art, music and community

A brass quintet at the Yale Music Shed at Weekend in Norfolk 2025.

Jennifer Almquist

Norfolk bursts with activity in midsummer with Weekend in Norfolk (WIN). An all-volunteer committee transforms the town with free public events for all ages. WIN 2026 begins Thursday, July 30, and runs through Sunday, Aug. 2.

Norfolk sculptor Jon Riedeman, the new head of Norfolk Artists and Friends (NAF), organized the group’s 19th annual art exhibition, featuring paintings, sculpture, photography and jewelry by area artists in the Art Barn on the grounds of the Norfolk Chamber Music Festival. Riedeman expanded the show this year by inviting artists from New Marlborough, Massachusetts, to participate. The exhibit opens with a reception Thursday, July 30, from 5 to 7 p.m.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.