Luddites go Hollywood

News Of Very Narrow Interest

Maybe I’m overly sensitive but it bugs me when someone assumes you do not know how to use a piece of technology because you choose not to use it. Why don’t you answer my texts? Don’t you carry a cellphone? You’re not on Instagram? How do you know what’s going on? Today, someone who refuses to engage with technology is branded a Luddite, an inept technophobe. Apparently, rampant “tech-shaming” is one of the last bastions of permissible bullying and anyone who is not an “early adopter” is considered fair game. This is ignorant and unfair, particularly to the Luddites.

In early 1800’s England, a group of artisans and textile workers, the Luddites, staged a workers’ revolt against the factory owners. As machinery was being introduced into the workplace in the name of efficiency and cost-savings, they saw their employment and wages suffer, product quality decline, and working conditions worsen. They were not opposed to machines. In fact, many of them were highly-skilled machine operators.

While the owners and the British government characterized them as standing in the way of progress, their demands were actually quite progressive, arguing for a share of the savings in the form of better wages, training and apprenticeship programs, and pension and retirement benefits. Even their name had more than a whiff of modernity. ‘Luddites’ were followers of Ned Ludd, a mythical person who never actually existed. Having a virtual leader, an avatar. You can’t get much more modern than that. Think what the Luddites would have done with TikTok!

Eventually, the government tired of the Luddites smashing machinery as a negotiating tactic and British troops made short order of the protesters, including hanging a few of the leaders. A 19th century version of collective bargaining. Industrialization was saved and for decades dehumanizing and dangerous factory work and exploitive child labor was tacitly accepted by many as the price of progress.

Which brings us to the Hollywood writers’ strike. Like the Luddites, they feel threatened by machinery, the virtual machinery of streaming and artificial intelligence (AI). The writers see AI as limiting their employment opportunities, capping their wages and producing a homogenized product. The use of AI eliminates many of the entry level jobs which helped writers learn their craft and move up the ranks. Streaming makes it more difficult to receive residual payments from hit TV shows. Lower pay, less jobs, an inferior product, no training and limited career advancement with an uncertain retirement horizon. Sound familiar?

Everything old is new again. Normally, Hollywood would be cranking out screenplays about the sinister threat posed by these insidious technologies. But alas, they are on strike and no such scripts are forthcoming.

M.A. Duca is a resident of Twin Lakes, narrowly focused on everyday life.

Latest News

Feedback sought at public forum as part of a five-year improvement plan for County’s Family Services

Sabrina Jaar Marzouka led the Oct. 2 Department of Community and Family Services Forum.

Krista Briggs

POUGHKEEPSIE — On the evening of Wednesday, Oct. 2, the Dutchess County Department of Community and Family Services (DCFS) held an open forum at the Department of Mental Health to discuss a five-year Child and Family Services (CFS) Plan.

Fiscal and staffing challenges aside, the focus of DCFS remains on refining the five-year plan, meeting its targets and serving the county’s most vulnerable residents, many of whom depend on these supports simply to survive.

Keep ReadingShow less
Finding my footing: adventures in a new home
Scenes from a day of exploration and hydration in the Northwest Corner.
Alec Linden

On a cloudy Wednesday at the start of October, my girlfriend, Taylor, and I decided to enjoy the autumn afternoon by getting off our laptops and into the woods for some much needed movement. Having just moved to Norfolk as a new reporter for the Lakeville Journal, I was on the hunt for panoramic views of the landscape I now call home, accessible with the hour and a half of daylight left to us. Haystack Tower it was.

I’m not entirely unfamiliar with the landscapes of the Northwest Corner: I visited family and friends in the region as a child and would drive up on high school joyrides from my home in Westchester County. But calling somewhere home brings new meaning to a place, and I was eager to see a familiar view with a new sense of belonging.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kent unveils juried art show
Leila Hawken

Chilly rain sprinkles did not keep area art lovers away from the opening of the Kent Art Association’s Fall Juried Art Show on Sunday, Oct. 13. Judges for the event were association members Liz Maynard and Conrad Levenson. The show will continue until Saturday, Nov. 2, during the association's open hours.

Kent artist and long-term resident Carolyn Millstein (above) paused for a photo next to her piece, “Near Oakdale."

SHELTER show opens at Royal Arcanum Building in Norfolk
Natalia Zukerman

“SHELTER,” an art exhibit supporting The Gathering Place opened on Suday, Oct. 12, at the Royal Arcanum Building in Norfolk, Conn. Featuring works by fourteen area artists, proceeds from sales will benefit The Gathering Place based in Torrington, Conn., which provides essential services to the homeless across 26 towns in Litchfield County. Open weekdays, this vital resource offers everything from hot showers and laundry facilities to housing assistance. The exhibit runs through Nov. 24.