Dollar story: Dollar General application still in limbo

The proposed location of a Dollar General store east of the driving range on Route 44 in Millerton.

John Coston

Dollar story: Dollar General application still in limbo

NORTH EAST — The status of the application to build a Dollar General store on Route 44 next to The Talk of the Towne in the Town of North East remains unclear.

To date, Lorna Sherman, bookkeeper and budget officer in the Town of North East, confirmed that the Dollar General application has not been withdrawn, and remains open but inactive.

During the July 12, 2023, meeting of the North East Planning Board, Robert Trotta, the applicant, was asked to place $4,000 in escrow to cover legal fees and the expenses of the town planner, Will Agresta, “to see if the plan as it stands is worthy of going forward,” according to minutes from the meeting.

In August and September, deductions were made to the account totaling $1,312.50, and Agresta provided the applicant with a memo identifying the deficiencies in the site plan as presented.

There has been no further communication from Trotta with the Town, but neither has there been a request for refunding the fee.

The plan as it stands is to build a store on Route 44 on the 2.7-acre empty lot now occupied by the driving range next to the Talk of the Towne and Trotta’s Liquors store, all owned by Trotta. The building would be 12,000 square feet with parking for 40 cars. Inside, 3,000 square feet would be devoted to fresh produce.

During the North East Planning Board meeting July 12, 2023, Chairman Dale Culver observed that “This particular type of store might undercut the future plans for development.”

Recently, Culver explained to The Millerton News his reason for making the comment: “This was the elephant in the room. Everyone felt the same way but no one wanted to say anything.”

The Town Board met Sept. 14, 2023, and rejected the idea of a six-month moratorium requested by the Zoning Review Committee (ZRC) for accepting new applications for development on Route 44.

Town Supervisor Christopher Kennan said at the time: “The difficulty that I have with this is that there is an application in front of the Planning Board for which a fee has already been received, and it is the only application in front of the Planning Board on the boulevard for this, so this strikes me as being very much targeted at one particular application.”

Warren Replansky, town attorney, has commented, “It may not be right to issue a moratorium [...] until we know more about where the committee is in the process.”

Since September last year, no moratorium has been enacted, Trotta has not come back to the board with any modifications for the proposed Dollar General Store, and the ZRC has not drafted final commercial zoning regulations.


The original version of this story ran with an inaccurate headline. The application is with the North East Planning Board and not with the town’s Zoning Review Committee.

Latest News

Upstate Art Weekend brightens Wassaic and beyond

Maxon Mills in Wassaic hosted a majority of the events of the local Upstate Art Weekend events in the community.

Photo by Mia Barnes

WASSAIC — Art enthusiasts from all over the country flocked to the Catskill Mountains and Hudson Valley to participate in Upstate Art Weekend, which ran from July 18 to July 21.

The event, which “celebrates the cultural vibrancy of Upstate New York”, included 145 different locations where visitors could enjoy and interact with art.

Keep ReadingShow less
Green thumbs drawn to Amenia Garden Tour

A serene scene during the Garden Tour in Amenia.

Photo by Leila Hawken

AMENIA — The much-anticipated annual Amenia Garden Tour drew a steady stream of visitors to admire five local gardens on Saturday, July 13, each one demonstrative of what a green thumb can do. An added advantage was the sense of community as neighbors and friends met along the way.

Each garden selected for the tour presented a different garden vibe. Phantom’s Rock, the garden of Wendy Goidel, offered a rocky terrain and a deep rock pool offering peaceful seclusion and anytime swims. Goidel graciously welcomed visitors and answered questions about the breathtaking setting.

Keep ReadingShow less
Tangled Lines: Casting into depths at dawn

Gary Dodson working a tricky pool on the Schoharie Creek, hoping to lure something other than a rock bass from the depths.

Photo by Patrick L. Sullivan

PRATTSVILLE, N.Y. — The Schoharie Creek, a fabled Catskill trout stream, has suffered mightily in recent decades.

Between pressure from human development around the busy and popular Hunter Mountain ski area, serious flooding, and the fact that the stream’s east-west configuration means it gets the maximum amount of sunlight, the cool water required for trout habitat is simply not as available as in the old days.

Keep ReadingShow less