Learning To Cook the Old-Fashioned Way

I’m a relative newcomer to this part of the world, having only arrived in 1993. Therefore, my collection of nonprofit community cookbooks comes mainly from the transfer station swap shop.

Mary Kirby, on the other hand, has been here long enough (and is of course a generous supporter of nonprofits) to have many such cookbooks, all of which she actually purchased.

I was sitting in my office one morning looking through my three community cookbooks when Mary walked in, and I began to read out the names of local cooks who had contributed recipes; of course she knew most or all of them, which was fun. And then she offered to loan me three from her own collection.

Of course Mary and I both have the essential Salisbury cookbook, which was published by the Town Hill School (which is now part of Indian Mountain School). This collection — called “Favorite Recipes from Friends* (*Some Famous)” includes donated recipes from the collections of Mrs. Ronald Reagan, actor Paul Newman and the Princess of Wales, all of whom are adjacent to the Northwest Corner in various ways.

But the best reason to have the Town Hill collection is that it is at the crux of the Famous Salisbury Tomato Pie War, which has been written about often enough in The Lakeville Journal that we can ignore it for the purposes of this article.

One of the delights of a New England community cookbook is the names of the contributing cooks. Some are exotic (Bedelia Falls, Knirps Wilson).  Some evoke well-known locals who are no longer with us; it’s a fun exercise in nostalgia and storytelling to go through one of these books with someone who’s lived here for a long time and knows all the players.

Although there are recipes for all seasons (especially ones that use up Litchfield County’s abundant corn, zucchini and tomatoes), this article will focus on a few that are timeless and not sensitive to the season.

You will notice that most of these recipes come from cooks who do not live in Salisbury and you will wonder why this article is in a special publication dedicated to discovering the joys (culinary and otherwise) of this jewel of a town.

The answer is that the best place to find your own nonprofit cookbooks is at the Salisbury/Sharon transfer station on Route 44, which has a phenomenally good swap shop where people leave clean, previously loved items.

I rarely buy books any more, I mostly find unexpected and wonderful fiction and nonfiction at the swap. You can of course find many fancy actual cookbooks from many eras. But the nonprofit fundraising cookbooks are a particular treasure that you only find occasionally, and that you have to know to look for (like hunting for wild mushrooms).

You can only access the swap shop if you have a transfer station sticker; but my friends from out of town often ask if they can come peruse the selection of swap shop delights with me, so you can probably befriend a Salisbury or Sharon resident and ask to be invited.

Often the recipes in these nonprofit very local cookbooks have a little story that goes along with them; this is the case with a recipe contributed by Mrs. Kirby’s own husband, the late and very much beloved Ed Kirby — baseball coach, regional schools superintendent, historian and geologist. Appropriately, Ed’s contribution to several cookbooks is something he calls the Geologist’s Field Sandwich.

Geologist’s Field Sandwich

 

Ingredients: Two large slices of soft rye bread, creamy peanut butter, red currant jelly, dry roasted unsalted peanuts, banana

“The Geologist’s Field Sandwich is designed for the culinary inept and nongifted,” Kirby says. “Its purpose is primarily the provision of a staple to be consumed between a hearty breakfast and the evening meal. No Precambrian, Paleozoic or Ice Age contaminants are included in this recipe.

“Thickly spread one slice of bread with peanut butter. Cover the peanut butter with a liberal amount of unsalted peanuts. Using a spreader, firmly implant the nuts in the peanut butter. Slice several vertical strips of banana and place them over the nuts. Spread a liberal layer of currant jelly over the second slice of bread.

“For those persons with at least a tad of culinary expertise, strips of crisp bacon may be applied over the jelly. Carefully flip the jellied bread over the first slice and press the two together firmly. Pack in a plastic sandwich bag and head for the hills.

“For best results, it is recommended that this sedimentary delicacy be consumed on a high rock overlooking the scenic wonders of the Housatonic Valley, with a cold can of juice or soda, and a bit of semi-sweet chocolate. The energy for the rest of the day will be yours.”

Many recipes in these books — even those published in the 1980s and 1990s — rely on grocery store prepared foods such as canned soup and packaged white bread. This is surprising to me, because I am most familiar with the modern Litchfield County cooks who, in my unscientific experience, are almost fanatical about using only locally grown, organic fresh produce.

Cream of mushroom soup appears in many recipes. A more exotic canned soup is cream of celery, which forms the backbone of a dish called “Fancy Chicken” from Madeleine L’Engle, the author of the beloved children’s story “A Wrinkle in Time” and who for many years owned the general store in Goshen with her husband, the actor Hugh Franklin. Of this recipe (which is in the 1986 Town Hill School cookbook and which OF COURSE also includes cream of mushroom soup), she says, “Here is one of my favorite quick and easy party dishes!”

Fancy Chicken

Serves eight

Ingredients: Four chicken breasts, boned and cooked, two cans artichoke hearts, cut up, two cans water chestnuts, sliced, two cans cream of mushroom soup, one can cream of celery soup, lemon juice, Hellman’s mayonnaise, curry powder

“Cut up baked chicken in small pieces and place in the bottom of a casserole. Add artichoke hearts and water chestnuts. Make a sauce out of the mushroom soup, celery soup, lemon juice and mayonnaise; season with enough curry powder to give it a little bit of zip. Bake for 30 minutes at 350 degrees and serve. This can be prepared the night before, refrigerated and baked the next day.”

Another publishing celebrity from the Northwest Corner of Connecticut was Priscilla Buckley, older sister of the famous William F. and a resident since childhood of the Great Elm estate, along with her many brothers and sisters (and, in time, her many, many nieces and nephews). She was for most of her lifetime the managing editor of her brother’s magazine, called National Review (she wrote a book about those years, called “Living it up With National Review”).

No matter what your politics, you would have to have a heart of stone not to fall in love with Miss Buckley, who was tough as could be when she needed to be (I once commented that she was probably the only person on Earth who could force her famous younger brother to turn in his articles on time; she just giggled demurely) but was generally unbelievably kind, sweet and friendly.

One time she came in to my office at The Lakeville Journal to work on an obituary for someone in her family; even though she was already at an advanced age, she was able to remember the name of every single one of her nieces and nephews and which town those young people lived in. This is a rare feat, even for people with only a half dozen or so nieces and nephews.

As anyone knows who comes from a large family, simple recipes that can inexpensively feed a lot of people are prized. Priscilla Buckley was known as Aunt Pitts. This is a recipe she describes as “Very easy” (true journalists don’t waste words).

Aunt Pitts’ Casserole

Serves eight to 12

Ingredients: Two pounds hamburger, 2 pounds Velveeta cheese, 2 cups onions, chopped, two cans (5 cups) of tomatoes, one box of fettucini

“Brown the hamburger and onions. Slice the cheese in smallish slices. Cook noodles as directed on package. Use large casserole dish and layer ingredients, i.e., hamburger, cheese, tomatoes, noodles, hamburger, cheese, etc., saving a few slices of cheese. Cook in a warmed 350 degree oven for 90 minutes. Place remaining cheese on top for last 5 minutes. If more convenient, cook for first 45 minutes earlier in the day or the day before. Would be good with green peppers.”

I could continue on for pages and pages sharing some of the little gems from these wonderful cookbooks. But I will suggest that if you are able to gain access to the Salisbury/Sharon transfer station, keep an eye out for the Town Hill school cookbook, and also look out for one called “Favorite Recipes from the Northwest Corner,” a fundraising cookbook for the Noble Horizons Auxiliary in Salisbury. This is arguably the most sophisticated and modern of the fundraising cookbooks, and has several recipes for signature dishes from local restaurants (many of which are now closed).

A re-creation of the Geologist’s Field Sandwich, just as good now as it was when the late Ed Kirby first shared the recipe. Photo by Cynthia Hochswender

Look for these covers when searching for nonprofit cookbooks at tag sales or the swap shop.  Photo by Cynthia Hochswender

A re-creation of the Geologist’s Field Sandwich, just as good now as it was when the late Ed Kirby first shared the recipe. Photo by Cynthia Hochswender
Related Articles Around the Web

Latest News

Amenia board honors employees for service

Long-term town employees were recognized at the Town Board meeting on Thursday, June 12. Honorees pictured with Town Supervisor Leo Blackman, were Judy Carlson, Office Manager at the Town Garage, center, for her 35 years of service to the town and Megan Chamberlin, current Highway Superintendent, for 20 years.

Leila Hawken

AMENIA — Acknowledging the many years of service accumulated by town employees, the Town Board paused to honor that service at its meeting on Thursday, June 12.

“Thank you for making a difference,” said Town Supervisor Leo Blackman in recognizing Judy Carlson, Office Manager at the town garage, for her 35 years of service.

Keep ReadingShow less
Historic marker dedicated at Amenia Union Cemetery

In anticipation of the celebration of the 250th anniversary of the start of the American Revolution in 2026, new historic markers are appearing at each of the local cemeteries where Revolutionary War veterans are buried. Unveiling the new marker at Amenia Union Cemetery on Saturday, June 21, were left to right, Town Historian Betsy Strauss, Jim Middlebrook representing the regional chapter of the Sons of the American Revolution, and Gail Seymour, President of the Union Cemetery Association.

Photo by Leila Hawken

AMENIA — One by one, new historic markers are appearing at local cemeteries where Revolutionary War dead are buried. On Saturday, June 21, community members gathered to see a new marker unveiled at Amenia Union Cemetery on Leedsville Road.

A tent provided welcome shade for the attendees and refreshments as about 30 residents gathered for the unveiling and to share stories of local history with one another.

Keep ReadingShow less
Millbrook Historical Society announces summer Quaker lecture series

The Nine Partners Road Quaker Meetinghouse, built in 1780, will be the site of two summer lectures sponsored by the Millbrook Historical Society.

Photo by Leila Hawken

MILLBROOK — Long in the planning, the Millbrook Historical Society has announced that it is sponsoring two lectures in observance of the 250th anniversary of the American Revolution. Both lectures relating to Quaker history are to be held in the historic Quaker Meeting House on Nine Partners Road.

For the first talk, scheduled for Sunday, June 29, at 2 p.m., the historical society has invited Sarah Gronningsater, Professor of History at the University of Pennsylvania, to talk on “Quakers, Anti-slavery, and the American Revolution.” The topic will explore the role that New York’s Quakers, especially in the Hudson Valley, played in the rise of the anti-slavery movement that followed the American Revolution.

Keep ReadingShow less
Millerton voter turnout declines after 2023 peak

Downtown Millerton

Photo by Aly Morrissey

MILLERTON — Voter turnout in the Village of Millerton dropped sharply in 2025, with just 58 ballots cast in this year’s village election — less than a third of the record turnout seen just two years earlier.

The election on June 17 marked a stark contrast to 2023, when signs littered the intersection of Route 22 and Route 44 and 208 voters headed to the polls to decide a competitive mayoral race between incumbent Jenn Najdek and challenger Kelly Kilmer. That year also featured two contested trustee positions and generated the highest turnout in at least five years.

Keep ReadingShow less