Millerton CVS site listed for over $3 million

The Millerton CVS property at 108 Route 44 was originally constructed in 1957 and renovated in 2005. The single-story building has 10,349 square feet on a 1.09 acre lot.

Photo by Christine Bates

Millerton CVS site listed for over $3 million

MILLERTON — The building where CVS operates in the Town of North East, and the parking lot next to it which is in the Village of Millerton, have been listed for sale on Loop Net, a commercial multiple listing service site, for $3,203,000.

The owner of the property is Naomi Djanogly Properties LLC which owns other commercial properties nationally.

The original building was constructed in 1957 and renovated in 2005. CVS’s monthly rent and the term and details of its lease have not been revealed. However, the return on the sale price of $3,203,000 with CVS as a tenant is estimated at 7.5%.

CVS management announced in 2021 a national “store realignment” which would close 900 locations between 2022 and 2024, and, recently indicated that another 270 stores would be closed in 2025.

In the last six months there have been numerous real estate transactions on the south side of Route 44.

Elizabeth’s Jewelry store location at 110 Route 44 was sold to the Bank of Millbrook for $896,000 on Oct. 8, 2024, and Elizabeth’s moved east on Route 44 into the former Trotta Liquor Store next to the Talk of the Town restaurant. Millerton Plaza, formerly the Grand Union supermarket location on 10.4 acres with over 36,000 square feet, was sold for $1.75 million on Nov. 15. Most recently The Millerton News reported that Tallow, a new type of fast-food endeavor, is in negotiations to occupy the former McDonald’s.

Latest News

Home field advantage holds true for Webutuck softball and baseball

Olivia Wickwire, no. 2, tags out a runner at first base. The Webutuck Warriors varsity softball team beat the Germantown Clippers 14-7 at home Friday, April 25.

Photo by Nathan Miller

AMENIA — Webutuck girls varsity softball beat visiting Germantown 14-7 Friday, April 25.


Keep ReadingShow less
Kent Hollow Mine case resolved after years of litigation
Amenia Town Hall
Photo by John Coston

AMENIA — The Town Baord signed a resolution bringing an end to a history of litigation between Amenia’s Zoning Board of Appeals and principals of Kent Hollow Mine at a special meeting on Thursday, April 24.

It was a brief meeting with no public discussion before the vote except to make a clarifying change in the resolution’s wording, suggested by the Special Counsel to the town, George Lithco.

Keep ReadingShow less
Historians and neighbors celebrate Revolutionary War veterans at old Amenia Burying Ground

Tim Middlebrook, President of the Columbia Mid-Hudson Valley chapter of the Sons of the American Revolution, left, Amenia Town Supervisor Leo Blackman, center, and Amenia Historical Society President Betsy Strauss unveiled a new historical marker at the Old Amenia Burying Ground on Saturday, April 26. The marker commemorates revolutionary war veterans buried at the cemetery where the Red Meeting House once stood on Mygatt Road.

Photo By Nathan Miller

AMENIA — Tim Middlebrook of the Sons of the American Revolution and Amenia Historical Society President Betsy Strauss unveiled a new historical marker honoring Revolutionary War vets in the Amenia Burying Ground.

Rain all morning had threatened the event, but historical society members, lovers of history and sons of the revolution persisted and the rain let up just in time.

Keep ReadingShow less
New priest takes the altar in Amenia

Father Andrew O'Connor

Photo by Christine Bates

AMENIA — Father Andrew O’Connor celebrated his first Easter at the Church of the Immaculate Conception after arriving in February to serve the parishioners of Amenia, Pine Plains and Millerton.

In an interview with The Millerton News, he commented that Easter was a time to see whole families together and meet young people home from college or prep school. His busy schedule includes masses on Friday, Saturday and Sunday, and another on Sunday night at Choate Rosemary Hall prep school when he visits his family in Connecticut.

Keep ReadingShow less