Should Trump be banned from Facebook, Twitter?

“Not freedom for the thought of those who agree with us, but freedom for the thought that we hate.”

 

This profound observation on free speech by the great American jurist Oliver Wendell Holmes has exceptions, which Holmes made clear in another First Amendment decision by noting that “speech that is false and dangerous is not protected” and no one is permitted  the freedom of “shouting ‘fire’ in a crowded theater, causing panic.” 

The Holmes remarks came to mind when pondering the decision by Facebook and Twitter to ban former president Trump indefinitely after he inspired a crowd to storm the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6.

Holmes’s words on the thoughts we hate are from a dissenting opinion in a 1929 Supreme Court  decision that blocked the citizenship application of a Hungarian immigrant named Rosika Schwimmer.

Schwimmer, in applying for the application, revealed that as a pacifist, she would not be willing to take up arms in defense of the United States. Even though Americans then, as now, had the right to conscientiously object to military service, the majority ruled that Schwimmer did not enjoy a citizen’s rights. 

Over the years, Holmes’s ideas  about limits on free speech had evolved. In 1919. he was part of a unanimous Court finding that the distribution of anti-draft leaflets  represented a clear and present danger to government recruitment in wartime.  He even likened the leafleting to falsely shouting fire in a theater.

But when wartime fever subsided, Holmes had second thoughts and in another leaflets case aimed at Russian immigrants supporting the Bolshevik Revolution.  “A silly leaflet by unknown men,” he wrote, was not a clear and present danger to the nation and “should not be illegal.” 

So how does all of this judicial thinking apply to the facts surrounding former president Trump’s loss of the use of Facebook  and Twitter because of the role his words played in inciting  the Jan.6 insurrection?

This final act of Trump’s tumultuous presidency resulted in death and destruction when his supporters attacked the Capitol while Congress was counting the 2020 electoral votes.  It was surely akin to falsely shouting fire in a crowded theater and was both dangerous and false.  And it was definitely not a silly speech by an unknown person. 

But Facebook is a private company and such organizations are not subject to the First Amendment. However, that doesn’t mean the  ban was fair and proper and Facebook had an independent committee of notables conduct an inquiry into its actions against Trump.

Former federal judge Michael McConnell, the co-chairman of that independent  committee, has pointed out there was no violation of the First Amendment because private companies can, indeed, violate the amendment.  Facebook and other social media can block whatever it deems unsuitable for whatever reason. However, they do so at the risk of offending public opinion, also known as their customers. Not to mention the trust busters in Congress, who can and do make laws upholding freedom of speech.

The committee  also noted Facebook doesn’t treat all of its users equally and needs to take a hard look at its standards before it finds Congress taking a hard look at its anti-trust status.  It criticized Trump’s ban and asked Facebook to reconsider.

What could amount to a lifetime ban on a former president, no matter how disreputable his conduct, is troubling.  This is especially true in Trump’s case if he follows through on his threat to run again in 2024. Every candidate should enjoy equal opportunity to reach voters.

And even though the First Amendment doesn’t apply here, our collective consciences should not ignore Holmes’s admonition about the truth we agree with and the truth we hate.

While writing this coIumn, I came upon another memorable admonition that has haunted me since I first read it as a student. It was made in 1930s by the great German theologian Martin Neimoller:

“First they came for the socialists but I did not speak out because I was not a socialist.

Then they came for the trade unionists but I did not speak out because I was not a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Jews but I did not speak out because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me and there was no one left to speak for me.”

And I thought maybe it was time to speak out, even for Donald Trump.

 

Simsbury resident Dick Ahles is a retired journalist. Email him at rahles1@outlook.com.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Millerton News and The News does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Another year of solar struggles, new hearings

Farmland vista where one of the proposed solar arrays for Hecate Energy's proposed Shepherd's Run solar energy array on Route 23 in Craryville, New York.

Photo by Nathan Miller

COPAKE – The past year marked another herky-jerky dance on the community solar front for this otherwise quiet hamlet.

As 2025 rolled along, the battle between Hecate Energy LLC and residents opposed to its proposed 42-megawatt Shepherd’s Run solar farm entered its eighth year.

Keep ReadingShow less
Year in review: A year of contrasts for Millerton

The Millerton Square plaza is still empty on Friday, Jan. 2, a little over eight months since the Town of North East Planning Board approved a site plan for major renovations to the grocery store in April.

Photo by Nathan Miller

MILLERTON – At a glance, Millerton’s year was marked by striking contrasts. Moments of division were set against moments of community building. Major municipal milestones were followed by delays and missed deadlines. And years-long efforts to prepare for the future unfolded alongside planning efforts to celebrate the past.

Fire ignites year of rebuilding

A Feb. 3 fire shaped what would become a year of rebuilding and resilience for the Village of Millerton. The early-morning blaze destroyed the highway and water department building, incinerating the village’s police vehicles, snow-removal equipment and everything inside the building.

Keep ReadingShow less
Year in review: Amenia advances major projects while community life thrives

Road crews began construction in August on a new sidewalk along Route 44 connecting Amenia’s town center to Beekman Park, a project scheduled for completion in spring 2026.

Photo by Leila Hawken

The past year in Amenia was marked by steady progress on infrastructure, preservation and community projects designed to improve daily life and position the town for future growth.

In March, the Town Board selected a contractor to extend the sidewalk along Route 44 between Broadway and Beekman Park, with construction beginning in August. When completed this spring, the project will provide a safer pedestrian connection between the town center and the park.

Keep ReadingShow less
Year in review: A year of pride, participation and progress in Millbrook

Family members of Army PFC Charles R. Johnson attended a May 29 ceremony at Nine Partners Cemetery dedicating a permanent marker recognizing Johnson’s Medal of Honor for valor during the Korean War.

Photo by Leila Hawken

MILLBROOK -- Throughout the year, a supportive Millbrook community turned out for civic participation and celebratory events, reinforcing strong local bonds while finding moments of shared pride and reflection.

Among the most significant was the long-sought recognition of PFC Charles R. Johnson, a Millbrook native who was posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor for extraordinary valor during the Korean War.

Keep ReadingShow less