Affordable homes remain available in Amenia despite extreme stratification

Affordable homes remain available in Amenia despite extreme stratification

This bungalow style home built in 1920 at 78 Old North Road sold for $320,000 with two bedrooms and 1.5 baths. Situated on .64 acres it has a generous front and back yard.

Photo by Christine Bates

AMENIA — September was a busy month in Amenia with 11 recorded transfers of residential, commercial and land parcels. Seven of these sales were in the affordable range under $350,000 while the remaining four, two houses and two building lots at Silo Ridge, were over $2 million with nothing in between.

Looking at the two most expensive homes sold highlights the disparity in price which perplexes many buyers, sellers and real estate professionals. A stately home on Smithfield Road in the desirable Shekomeko area of Amenia on 28.7 acres sold for $3.675 million, almost half the price of a similarly sized home in Silo Ridge on Wood Duck Road on .74 acres which sold for $7 million. Both properties sold for over their assessed values — Smithfield for 55% more, and Wood Duck for 24% over assessed value.
In mid-October, 21 single family homes were listed for sale with 11 under $500,000 and the most expensive at $20 million, according to OneKey MLS.

34 Glen Ave. — mobile home on .43 acres old for $98,900.

5327 Route 44 — small commercial building on .04 acres sold for $150,000.

1 Prospect Ave. — 3 bedroom/1 bath single family home on .6 acres sold for $223,300.

38 Glen Ave. — 3 bedroom/ 1 bath home on 1 acre sold for $230,000.

78 Old North Road — 2 bedroom/1.5 bath home on .64 acres sold for $320,000.

23 Yellow City Road — 3 bedroom/2 bath raised ranch sold for $335,540, the median price in September of all properties transferred.

53 Perry’s Corner Road — 3 bedroom/1 bath home sold for $349,900.

Redtail Pass (*658785) — .73 acre building lot at Silo Ridge sold for $2.19 million.

Ridgeline Road (*733429) — 1.54 acre building lot at Silo Ridge sold for $2.8 million.

20-22 Smithfield Road — 5 bedroom/4.5 bath home on 28.7 acres sold for $3.675 million.

232 Wood Duck Road — 4 bedroom/5 full bath/ 2 half bath home at Silo Ridge on .74 acres sold for $7 million.

* Town of Amenia real estate sales recorded between September 1, 2024, and September 30, 2024 sourced from Dutchess County Real Property Tax Service Agency. Information on active listings taken from First Key MLS. Parcel numbers refer to parcel designation by Dutchess County and may be accessed on Dutchess Parcel Access. Only transfers with consideration are included. Compiled by Christine Bates, Real Estate Advisor with William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty, Licensed in CT and NY.

Latest News

Pauline King Garfield

Pauline King Garfield

EAST CANAAN — Pauline K. (King) Garfield, 94 of 77 South Canaan Rd. formerly of East Canaan, died Sunday May 24, 2026, at Geer Village.She was the wife of the late Duane Garfield who passed August 14, 2017. Pauline was born April 3, 1932 in North Canaan, CT in the former Geer Hospital. She was the daughter of the late Charles and Rose (Van Vlack) King.

Pauline spent her career at Becton Dickinson in Canaan, after being a stay-at-home mother for many years.She was employed at Becton Dickinson for 23 years. She enjoyed bus trips with her late husband Duane to the Casinos, spending time with her family watching the grandchildren grow up. Recently she made a comment to care givers that was “wait until I see that husband of mine for leaving me here, I am going to read him the riot act.” Over the years she enjoyed many crafts, but her favorite was crocheting gifts for everyone.

Keep ReadingShow less

Let's hear it - May 28, 2026

Let's hear it - May 28, 2026

Last Week’s Question

What is one change you’d make to your town center to make it more welcoming?

Keep ReadingShow less
Memorial Day paraders brave wet weather

A ceremonial firing party honored fallen soldiers at Millerton’s American Legion on Route 44 on Monday, May 25. Legion representatives originally planned a parade down Millerton’s Main Street and a ceremony at the Veterans Park monument in front of the Methodist Church, but rain forced the events inside at American Legion Post 178.

Photo by Nathan Miller

Wet weather this past Memorial Day weekend cast a hazy drizzle over much of northeast Dutchess County, forcing holiday ceremonies inside in Millerton and Amenia.

Pine Plains and Millbrook pushed on with parades in those towns, attracting thronging crowds to Main Streets to mourn and reflect on the sacrifice of fallen soldiers.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Amenia to split rail trail maintenance with county
Amenia Town Hall on Route 22.
Photo by Nathan Miller

AMENIA — The Town of Amenia has approved a shared maintenance agreement for the Harlem Valley Rail Trail with Dutchess County and the Harlem Valley Rail Trail Association.

Town Board members accepted the agreement by unanimous vote at the regular meeting of the Town Board on Thursday, May 21.

Keep ReadingShow less
A blessing for pets — and a lifeline for their health
Lazarus, a Eurasian eagle owl, poses with Dr. Laura, his longtime handler. The rescue raptor — known as the event’s “wow factor” for his striking presence and six-foot wingspan — will appear as the Raptor Ambassador at Rhinebeck’s Blessing of the Animals.
provided

For many pet owners, animals are family. On Saturday, May 30, that bond will be celebrated in a uniquely practical and heartfelt way when the Blessing of the Animals returns to Third Lutheran Evangelical Church in Rhinebeck alongside a free rabies vaccination clinic hosted by Hudson Valley Animal Rescue & Sanctuary.

The event, scheduled from noon to 4 p.m., is free for Dutchess County residents and open to dogs, cats and domestic ferrets three months and older. While the clinic itself provides an important public health service, organizers say the day has become about much more than vaccinations.

Keep ReadingShow less

Growing community

Growing community

Sheila Srere, left, and Cathy Fenn plant flowers in a small island at the Harlem Valley Rail Trail’s intersection with Main Street in Millerton on Thursday, May 21.

Photo by Nathan Miller

A band of volunteers planted flowers across downtown Millerton on Thursday, May 21, as part of local group Townscape's annual beautification efforts. Community members from across northeast Dutchess County came together to plant flowers at Millerton's veterans memorial monument in front of the United Methodist Church on Main Street and in planters and flower beds along Main Street down to the intersection with Route 22.


Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.