Amenia’s decision to litigate with Kent Hollow Mine triggers petitions

WASSAIC — Those who live near the Kent Hollow Mine on South Amenia Road in Wassaic presumed that after the gravel mine applied to restart operations a number of years ago and were shot down by the town, the issue had been put to bed. However, resident Diane Zahler said while fiddling around on the internet around the end of March, she noticed the Town Board’s agenda for its March 16 meeting online.

“[It] included a discussion of the Kent Hollow mining project. I had thought that project had more or less disappeared; we hadn’t heard anything about it for at least two years,” said Zahler. “As our property directly adjoins Kent Hollow’s, we were alarmed by this, so I went to Town Hall to speak to Supervisor Victoria Perotti.”

Zahler said she asked Perotti what the board discussed at the March board meeting. Zahler said the town supervisor replied “that the town and Kent Hollow were working on a settlement.”

When Zahler asked what the settlement might include, Perotti said she couldn’t give any specific information, but she said that Kent Hollow ‘agreed’ to be put in the Soil Mining Overlay District, indicating that rather than just reopening under their grandfathered permit, they would be mining far more gravel far more frequently.

“Ms. Perotti assured me that the mining would not be a ‘24/7’ operation, and that the town would be able to control the days and hours on which mining took place,” said Zahler.

When asked on Friday, April 29, Perotti told this newspaper that “We’ve been in litigation for months,” though she couldn’t recall exactly when Kent Hollow filed its suit against the town. When asked if it was 2022, she said, “It seems like it’s been going on forever.”

When asked if it was 2021, Perotti said it was before that; when asked if it was 2020 she said she “really couldn’t recall the exact date,” but that the town is “standing by our ZBA and we’re in discussions, but nothing has been done, no settlement, no agreement, no nothing.”

The town supervisor said “the problem is they’re not grandfathered in and they’re not part of the Soil Mining Overlay we have as part of our zoning. Our ZBA ruled that they couldn’t do what they wanted to do, and then it started,” adding that “this is litigation, and it can’t be discussed, but the town did not decide to litigate; they’re the ones that filed the law suit.”

Perotti also stressed that “There’s no settlement — I don’t know where all this came from.”

But Zahler was taking no chances. After she spoke to Perotti, who she said told her that the town wanted to settle the matter rather than go through the time it would take to deal with a years’ long lawsuit, Zahler created two petitions.

“One [is] designed for Amenia/Wassaic residents simply to protest the reopening of the mine, the other a formal protest petition signed by property owners abutting or within 100 feet of the mine property to protest any rezoning that will take place as a result of the mine being placed in the Mining Overlay District,” she explained.

Her husband, Phil Sicker,  was able to get the signatures of nearly everyone whose property abuts the mine, said his wife, “all of whom were both shocked and angered by news of the upcoming settlement.”

Sicker said he was able to obtain 10 signatures on the one petition and then 27 signatures on the general petition in just more than a day.

“I don’t know of anybody who didn’t sign it other than one person who was sick,” he said. “People were unanimously appalled.”

Zahler submitted the two petitions to the deputy town clerk on Monday, April 18.

As the petition states, “The Zoning Board denied a change in zoning two years ago, making an increase in mining at the site illegal. However, Kent Hollow continued their efforts to expand the extent of their operations, and after months of deliberation, the Town Board has decided that negotiations are no longer in their economic interests. They agreed to a settlement.”

The petition went on to state that the result would lead to an “astronomical increase” in truck traffic, noise and air pollution and a sharp decrease in property values.

The document concludes that if the mine is successful in its litigation, it will prove that “businesses can buy out our town.”

The second, smaller petition of neighboring property owners of the mine located at 341 South Amenia Road, calls for the Town Board to invoke the “three-fourths rule.”

The rule “provides than any such amendment requires the approval of at least three-fourths of the members of a Town Board in the event that such amendment is the subject of a written protest, presented to the Town Board and signed by any one of the following three categories of local property owners: 1. the owners of 20% or more of the area of land included in such proposed change; 2. the owners of 20% or more of the area of land immediately adjacent to that land included in such proposed change, extending 100 feet therefrom; or 3. the owners of 20% or more of the area of land directly opposite thereto, extending 100 feet from the street frontage of such opposite land.”

Zahler said she and her husband are hoping residents will oppose the sudden reversal just to accommodate a wealthy and persistent business owner who isn’t even a town or state resident. Both she and Sicker said if the town changed the law for Kent Hollow it would set a dangerous precedent.

They also said the optics of dealing with the matters behind closed doors, with no discussion before the public, reflects poorly on the board.

“The back-and-forth with Kent Hollow has taken place in considerable secrecy, as far as I can tell,” said Zahler. This may be, in part, because several members of the board — Vicki Doyle, Leo Blackman, and Damian Gutierrez — are being sued by Kent Hollow, and Doyle and Blackman have been forced to recuse themselves. The remaining board members seem to be in favor of a settlement, one that will require a change in zoning that goes against the Amenia Master Plan. This settlement will reverse five years of resistance by the Town Board and the ZBA.

Perotti said that Gutierrez did not recuse himself, though, as he had no reason to.

Sicker agreed the reason the whole issue is so upsetting is because of the town’s lack of transparency.

“We’re asking that the Town Board continue with its defense of Amenia’s zoning restrictions as indications in the Master Plan that the previous town Supervisor Bill Flood articulated very clearly and the last four years up until now the Board and ZBA have ratified,” he said. “I think the word here is a betrayal. It’s a betrayal of the zoning restrictions map and the community who have elected these officials to enforce the law. The more you think of it, the more outrageous it becomes.”

Perotti defended her governing of the town, and said she has always been transparent.

“Whenever I have executive session I always say why, what it’s about, because that’s what you have to do in order to comply with the law,” she said.

She added the issue so far is not on the board’s agenda for its meeting on Thursday, May 5.

Latest News

Participants at annual conference encouraged to ThinkDifferently by respecting evolving etiquette norms

Top row (left to right): Panelist Shadei Williams; Dana Hopkins, Dutchess County All Abilities Program Director; panelist Johnny Vacca; Dutchess County Executive Sue Serino. Bottom row: (left to right): Panelist Wayne Robinson; panelist Tracy Wallace; panelist Samantha Van Alstyne

Provided

HYDE PARK, N.Y. — On Thursday, Dec. 5, the annual ThinkDifferently conference was held at the Henry A. Wallace Visitor and Educational Center in Hyde Park, New York. The conference strived to enlighten participants on evolving protocols for addressing and collaborating with individuals with challenges.

Hosted by Dana Hopkins, program director of All Abilities at the Department of Behavioral and Community Health, ThinkDifferently is an initiative first launched in 2015 by former county executive Marc Molinaro with a goal to provide services to individuals with varying abilities and guidance for others such as businesses and communities to help create a more inclusive society.

Keep ReadingShow less
Shooting the breeze with Christopher Little

Martin Tandler

Little with his dog, Ruby.

"What I really feel lucky about is having had the chance to meet and photograph so many people who had a real impact on our lives,” said Christopher Little whose new memoir, “Shooting the Breeze: Memories of a Photojournalist” was just released. The book is as eclectic and colorful as the man himself and offers an intimate look into Little’s globe-trotting career spent behind the lens, capturing some of the most iconic figures, events, and human stories of the past half-century.

In 2021, the Dolph Briscoe Center for American History at The University of Texas acquired Little’s photographic archive.

Keep ReadingShow less
Cold Spring, a not-so-hidden Hudson Valley gem

“Cold Spring, NY” depicts life in a notable Hudson River town with a rich history and much natural beauty.

Krista A. Briggs

According to Alissa Malnati, co-creator of the new coffee table tome, “Cold Spring, NY”, after twenty-five years in the urban jungle, it was time to go in search of a cure for the angst which, for some, can come with metropolitan living. “My husband and I were soul sick,” explained Malnati of the couple’s move to Cold Spring, a Hudson River town located in leafy Putnam County. “We were seeking restoration and quiet, and to be in nature, away from the hustle and bustle of the city.”

The time was right for a move in 2021. The Malnatis relocated from busy Brooklyn to a tranquil mountaintop abode which allowed them to decompress without the intrusion of cell phones and ceaseless city noise. With the shift to the Hudson Valley, Alissa, a writer and fashion executive, and her husband, Will, a podcaster and television producer, found the peace they were searching for in Cold Spring, a semi-rural town known for its boutiques, antique shops, and world-class hiking trails.

Keep ReadingShow less