Prop One debate split on party lines

ALBANY — Dutchess County voters will have one statewide measure on the back of their ballots on Election Day: an amendment to the state constitution listed as “Prop. One” and commonly known as the equal rights amendment.

Prop One amends the anti-discrimination section of the state constitution, codifying protections for “ethnicity, national origin, age, disability ... or sex, including sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, pregnancy, pregnancy outcomes, and reproductive healthcare and autonomy.”

New York Democrats have widely touted the measure as a key protection for abortion, while Republicans have slammed the measure, calling it a trojan horse that does little to specifically address abortion rights in the state.

Albany Law assistant professor Dale Cecka has spent her professional career in family law with an academic focus on the constitutional rights of parents. She said the New York GOP’s claims that the amendment would allow non-citizens to vote in the state and strip parent’s rights are false and have no basis in the text of the amendment.

“It’s largely symbolic,” Cecka said. “It doesn’t create any new rights.” She explained that the text of this amendment creates some useful redundancy and clear direction for state courts, but doesn’t expand on existing anti-discriminatory statutes like the U.S. Civil Rights Act of 1964, which already federally prohibits discrimination based on ethnicity and national origin.

She also said that, in New York, existing abortion protections and protections against sex- and gender-based discrimination already secure the right to an abortion in the state. This amendment to the state constitution simply adds one more layer of legal protection to prevent the government from future action that may infringe on those rights.

Prop. One will appear on the back of Dutchess County ballots. Voters can read the full text of the proposition online at elections.ny.gov/2024-statewide-ballot-proposal.

Latest News

Troutbeck Symposium 2025: the latest chapter in continuing a vital legacy

Participating students and teachers gathered for the traditional photo at the 2025 Troutbeck Symposium on Thursday, May 1.

Leila Hawken

Students and educators from throughout the region converged at Troutbeck in Amenia for a three-day conference to present historical research projects undertaken collaboratively by students with a common focus on original research into their chosen topics. Area independent schools and public schools participated in the conference that extended from Wednesday, April 30 to Friday, May 2.

The symposium continues the Troutbeck legacy as a decades-old gathering place for pioneers in social justice and reform. Today it is a destination luxury country inn, but Troutbeck remains conscious of its significant place in history.

Keep ReadingShow less
Roaring Oaks Florist launches self-serve flower market

Terence S. Miller, owner of Roaring Oaks Florist in the new self-serve area of the shop.

Natalia Zukerman

Just in time for Mother’s Day, Roaring Oaks Florist in Lakeville has launched a new self-serve flower station next to its Main Street shop, offering high-quality, grab-and-go bouquets from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., seven days a week — including Sundays when the main store is closed.

Owner Terence S. Miller, who bought the shop 24 years ago at just 20 years old, calls the new feature “a modern twist on an old-school honor system,” with some high-tech updates.

Keep ReadingShow less
Third graders enjoy classical treat at Music Mountain

A string quartet opened the Bard Conservatory of Music program for Region One third grade students at Music Mountain.

Patrick L. Sullivan

Region One third grade students attended a chamber music concert by Bard Conservatory of Music students at Music Mountain Tuesday, April 29.

After expending spare energy racing around the Music Mountain lawn, the children trooped into the concert hall and took their seats.

Keep ReadingShow less