AMENIA — The Planning Board voted unanimously Thursday, Nov. 12, to keep the public hearing on the proposed Cascade Creek subdivision open until its Dec. 9 meeting.
The hearing began Oct. 28. At Thursday’s meeting, residents raised concerns about water supply, septic systems, traffic and how the proposed workforce housing would benefit local families.
As the hearing opened, Peter Sander, Civil Engineer for the developer, Hudson River Housing, said that the Planning Board is not expected to act as a legislative body.
“Your role is to be sure that a project complies with zoning regulations,” Sander said, noting that several studies have already been provided to the board by the developer.
About water supply and wells, Sander said that the developer is eager to ensure an adequate water supply, but test wells cannot be dug until the board issues a preliminary subdivision approval. Future water testing will be required by the Health Department, which Peter said is also waiting on preliminary approval.
Acting as moderator for the public hearing, planning board member Jamie Vitiello began with a report from the board attorney that several letters had been received since the earlier public hearing and had been entered into the record.
Resident Margaret Deister spoke to dispute the size of the parcel being developed, suggesting that an independent surveyor should be hired to resolve discrepancies in plan iterations. She also suggested independent studies be conducted to verify the developer’s assessments of risk to endangered species in the area.
The obligations of the Homeowners Association that would oversee the administration of the development once built were of interest to resident George Bistransin.
Resident Judy Moran raised the issue of septic system design and maintenance and asked about plans for any sprinkler systems. And, she urged the planning board to follow workforce housing regulations.
Seeking to identify areas of local benefit represented by the Cascade Creek project, resident Bob Powell said that the project is said to offer workforce housing, but he wondered how local families might benefit.
“Residents do not support this project,” Powell said. He said that lower density housing on larger lots could change those views, and he suggested an independent study of aquifer effects.
“Affordable housing should not come at the expense of local character,” said resident Kim Travis, adding that serious consideration should be given to traffic impact.
Proposed by the nonprofit Hudson River Housing, the 24-acre site on Cascade Road would be divided into 26 residential lots to be used for single family workforce housing, modular in design, on quarter-acre lots. The homes would be sold to first-time home buyers who would each be eligible for funding to assist with mortgage down payments.
Zoned as Suburban Residential, the parcel lies within an Aquifer Overlay District with a portion standing within a stream corridor. The site is located across Route 22 from the Freshtown Shopping Plaza.
The preliminary subdivision planning has included a long environmental impact analysis phase that began in 2024 with a report only completed in July this year. The report indicated that the subdivision plans would have no significant environmental impact.

















