Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

Post Office robbery, railroad reorganization

The following excerpts from The Millerton News were compiled by Kathleen Spahn and Rhiannon Leo-Jameson of the North East-Millerton Library.

October 31, 1935

Amenia Post Office Robbed, Safe Blasted

Loot Valued At Hundreds Of Dollars Taken Sunday Night

AMENIA - Burglars entered the post office on Main Street here at about midnight Sunday and blasted open the safe, making their get-away with loot valued at several hundred dollars. Taken from the safe were about $350 worth of stamps. $150 in cash, a $25 savings bond, blank U.S. Treasury checks and U. S. postal money order blanks, a number of domestic orders and many official government documents and papers. The checks can be cashed after the amounts are filled in.

Some of the post office supplies and receipts are kept in the Amenia bank, it was disclosed by Mrs. Clayton M. Card, wife of the postmaster, and only funds and supplies needed for the day’s business were kept in the post office.

Fingerprints taken from the safe and from a rear window, through which the thugs made their entrance and exit, have been studied by postal inspectors who are being assisted in their investigation of the theft by Corporal Edwin Draisey of the Amenia Station, State Police, and fingerprint experts. Believing the robbery to be the work of professional safe crackers, the investigators have examined photographs on file in the rogues’ gallery, in New York.

The post office is situated in the Masonic building, four doors east of the state highway intersection. Half of the lower floor of the three-story structure is occupied by the post office and the other half by Arthur Newman’s sporting goods store. The second and third floors are utilized by the Masonic Lodge.

Forcing the rear window and a door to get into the post office, the thieves drilled a hole in the door of the safe which they filled with an explosive believed to have been nitro-glycerine. A fuse was inserted and a length of copper wire connected this with a battery behind the door. The first charge apparently blew off the door. The authorities believe at least two men participated in the job, one acting as look-out man while the other opened the safe.

Expect Action Of Railroad To Hit Dutchess

Anticipate Financial Consequences In New Haven’s Move

Reorganization sought by the New York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad under Section 77 of the federal bankruptcy act is expected to have far reaching financial consequences in Dutchess County. In similar cases, other railroads have tried to abandon unprofitable lines, and if this is attempted by the New York, New Haven and Hartford, service may be discontinued on three branch roads in the county.

The valuation of the railroad’s special franchise and real property in the county is $3,236,236.

On this assessment it paid a total of $106,174.49 to the cities, townships and county in 1934. The railroad’s total tax bill in the county for a single year is estimated at $150,000 since it also pays school taxes to union free schools and common school districts in those districts where it owns property. The railroad paid almost $45,000 in school taxes in Dutchess County in 1934, it is estimated.

An unsuccessful attempt was made by the New Haven just before it went into bankruptcy to borrow $5,000,000 from the RFC. A large portion of this money was sought for the payment of taxes.

The railroad has outstanding in bonds,[sic] which are prior liens, against its property in Dutchess County, $12,513,000. These bonds are not in default.

Because of bus and automobile competition, passenger service has been abandoned on the various New Haven lines in the county as unprofitable. The transportation of bituminous and anthracite coal has been the biggest item of business, this comprising about thirty percent of the entire freight traffic. Most of this tonnage is hauled over the former C. N. E. lines by way of the Poughkeepsie Bridge. The C. N. E. was merged with the New Haven system in 1927. A controlling interest in the New York, Ontario and Western Railroad is also owned by the New Haven.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Millerton News and The News does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

NECC announces new Executive Director

NECC announces new Executive Director

Athena Fliakos

Photo provided

MILLERTON — The North East Community Center has named Lakeville resident Athena Fliakos as its new executive director. She will begin Nov. 2, filling a position that has been vacant since March.

Fliakos said she is joining the organization during a difficult economic period nationally that requires adaptation from everyone — especially nonprofits.

Keep ReadingShow less
Amenia Library budget proposition misses election deadline

AMENIA — Town Board members have taken action to secure additional funding for the Amenia Free Library after ballot proposition paperwork failed to make it to election officials on time.

Amenia Free Library Executive Director Victoria Herow said library board members had worked to collect necessary signatures by June 29 for a ballot proposition to ask voters for a $10,000 budget increase. Then, on Aug. 22, she was informed that the paperwork had reached the Dutchess County Board of Elections after the deadline and was ineligible for this year’s election.

Keep ReadingShow less
Dutchess County early education pilot program takes shape

From left: Louise McLoughlin, Himali Pandya, and Sabrina Jaar Marzouka stand with New York OCFS Commissioner Dr. DaMia Harris-Madden and Jill Roche Gomez at the Poughkeepsie BOCES center on Thursday, Oct. 15.

Photo by Graham Corrigan

POUGHKEEPSIE — The shortage of early education in Dutchess County costs the local economy more than $320 million a year, advocates said at an Oct. 15 business roundtable in Poughkeepsie.

The figure puts a price on a problem that parents and business owners in northeastern Dutchess have been describing for months, and underscores the importance of the county’s upcoming pilot program to approach the problem from a multi-faceted perspective.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Sisters Hill Farm in talks with a prospective buyer who would keep it a working farm

STANFORDVILLE — Three months after announcing that Sisters Hill Farm was for sale, the Sisters of Charity of New York said leadership is in talks with a prospective buyer who intends to keep the property a working farm and continue its community-supported agriculture program.

In a letter earlier this month to farm members, the congregation’s leadership team said the prospective buyers share a commitment to preserving the farm and its mission. Farmer David Hambleton will continue to play “an important role” in its future, the letter said.

Keep ReadingShow less
Stanford home prices drop slightly after slower September sales

Located on a Stanford dirt road designated as “scenic,” 421 Conklin Hill Road is a single level 1,436 square foot home which sold for $571,430.

Photo by Christine Bates

STANFORD — At the end of September, median single family home prices dropped to $623,000 on lower unit sales volume.

The median price at the end of September represents a 4% drop since the year prior. According to real estate transaction data provided by New York State, Stanford home prices hit a median of $650,000 for the 12 months ending Sept. 30, 2025.

Keep ReadingShow less
Dutchess County Sheriff's Report — Thursday, October 29, 2026

Dutchess County Sheriff's Report — Thursday, October 29

Archive photo

Dutchess County Sheriff’s Office Harlem Valley area activity report Oct. 15 to Oct. 21

Oct. 17 — Deputies arrested Kevin Antonio Nahje Brathwaite, age 29, for aggravated unlicensed operation of a motor vehicle subsequent to a traffic stop in the Town of North East. Subject to appear in court at a later date.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.