MILLERTON — Irving Farm is giving its longtime Main Street coffee shop a “retail refresh” from front to back, with a new partner set to reopen the kitchen after months of intermittent food service.
Central to the makeover is the inclusion of Peter O’Reilly, who will take over Irving’s kitchen to serve his Board Man Bagels and cream cheese. The new Irving menu will include a variety of bagels for $3 each, half-pound containers of cream cheese for $7.50 and occasional specials.
The partnership is part of a larger overhaul at the Millerton mainstay. Irving co-founder Steven Leven said the cafe is undergoing a renovation as part of a refresh, following a summer where the kitchen was closed due to high staff turnover and rising costs. The new Irving will have a “more relevant, cozier feel,” Leven said.
The renovations are ongoing, and the shop was closed on Nov. 17 to accommodate the work.
Leven said the changes follow a difficult stretch for the business. “We had to cut back a lot just to survive,” Leven said.
Those challenges prompted Leven to make changes throughout the shop. The work so far includes fresh paint and new structural supports in the basement. Leven also plans to replace the kitchen flooring.
“These are things that I’ve wanted to do for a long time, but just couldn’t with the store open all the time.”
Leven also wanted to bring in a local baker to run the kitchen.

O’Reilly’s Board Man Bagels are already well-knownin Millerton. For the past year, he’s made his Saturday batches in the Tri Corner F.E.E.D. kitchen on South Center Street, turning out 200 to 250 bagels each week. For his first weekend at Irving Farm, he rolled 600.
O’Reilly is the first graduate of what he calls “the Tri-Corner F.E.E.D. business incubator.” The grocery store makes a habit of opening its space up to small, local businesses. After routinely selling out on Saturdays, O’Reilly was looking for room to expand when Leven approached him about a partnership.
Leven has been an enthusiastic Board Man customer. “My wife was bringing home bagels every weekend,” Leven said, “and they were the best bagels we ever had.”
The Irving Farm kitchen, given its struggles, ended food service during summer, and switched to serving coffee and pastries only.
“It’s really sad,” Leven said, reflecting on the period when the kitchen was closed. “I’m in there every week, and it’s just sad to see the kitchen closed. People are upset, and there are a lot of hurt feelings.”
When they met, O’Reilly and Leven “saw eye-to-eye about the store’s potential,” Leven said, and the two came to an agreement.
“We’re not making this complex,” O’Reilly said. “I don’t have the experience of running a whole kitchen. I know how to make bagels.”
O’Reilly is from nearby Sharon, Connecticut, and attended Housatonic Valley Regional High School. He said his first memories of Irving are from its early days — the Millerton location opened in 2003.
“I remember it used to be really busy in the evenings, with beer and wine and open mics,” he said.
O’Reilly came to an agreement with Irving: he’ll boil and bake the bagels in the back, and Irving will sell them at the front. Two part-time staffers will help with bagel production. A cut of Board Man’s sales will go to Irving.
O’Reilly bought two new TurboFan ovens for the kitchen. They now sit to the left of Irving’s six-burner stove. Irving already had some mixers available for Board Man: the biggest is a 40-quart behemoth that sits on the floor with its own rolling caddy. Once assembled, the bagels rest overnight in Irving’s walk-in refrigerator. That’s where the yeasty magic happens. “It really helps develop the flavor,” O’Reilly said.
“I try to incorporate local producers as much as possible,” O’Reilly said of his cooking process. “I’ve made a nice pumpkin cream cheese with Steelbow Farm pumpkins. I’ve used Thistle Pass tomatoes for sandwiches.”
The menu is small for now, but O’Reilly has plans to expand as his team becomes more comfortable in the space. Square pizzas and breakfast focaccia, proven Board Man classics, will be among the early additions.
So far, O’Reilly says, the community support has been a humbling experience. “People around here are so excited to support each other,” he said, “especially an upstart business that just wants to figure it out.”
He worked in the educational tech industry for years, but the pandemic pushed his breadmaking hobby to a new level. “For 5 years, I had a note in my phone that had ‘make sourdough bagels’ on my to-do list,” he said.
O’Reilly tweaked his sourdough version of longtime Bon Appetit editor Claire Saffitz’s bagels for 2 years. Then came a moment the bagelmaker describes as “borderline existential.”
“I just could not envision myself being on Zoom calls for the next 25 years,” he said. A disenchantment with the industry at large.“We were told, ‘Hey, Silicon Valley is good, good good,’” O’Reilly said. “But we’ve learned that lesson now.”
As for the name? It’s an homage to enigmatic NBA great Kawhi Leonard, who christened himself “Board Man” early in his basketball career. “I love Kawhi,” said O’Reilly. “He’s very unique, he’s a fun guy. He seems out of place in the personalities of the NBA. And when he’s healthy, his best basketball is just as good as LeBron James’. Naming something is always a weird little challenge.”












Millbrook celebrated Veterans Day with a color guard, a performance of “Taps,” and speeches from service members in honor of local war hero Charles Johnson.Photo by Graham Corrigan




